Who do you choose? Employees' perceptions of artificial intelligence versus humans in performance feedback
Authors:
Open Access
- 15 July 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in China Accounting and Finance Review
- Vol. 26 (4) , 512-532
Abstract
Purpose: Firms have already begun integrating artificial intelligence (AI) as a replacement for conventional performance management systems owing to its technological superiority. This transition has sparked a growing interest in determining how employees perceive and respond to performance feedback provided by AI as opposed to human supervisors.Design/methodology/approach: A 2 x 2 between-subject experimental design was employed that was manipulated into four experimental conditions: AI algorithms, AI data, highly experienced human supervisors and low-experience human supervisor conditions. A one-way ANOVA and Welch t-test were used to analyze data.Findings: Our findings revealed that with a predefined fixed formula employed for performance feedback, employees exhibited higher levels of trust in AI algorithms, had greater performance expectations and showed stronger intentions to seek performance feedback from AI algorithms than highly experienced human supervisors. Conversely, when performance feedback was provided by human supervisors, even those with less experience, in a discretionary manner, employees' perceptions were higher compared to similar feedback provided by AI data. Moreover, additional analysis findings indicated that combined AI-human performance feedback led to higher levels of employees' perceptions compared to performance feedback solely by AI or humans.Practical implications: The findings of our study advocate the incorporation of AI in performance management systems and the implementation of AI-human combined feedback approaches as a potential strategy to alleviate the negative perception of employees, thereby increasing firms' return on AI investment.Originality/value: Our study represents one of the initial endeavors exploring the integration of AI in performance management systems and AI-human collaboration in providing performance feedback to employees.Keywords
This publication has 50 references indexed in Scilit:
- Towards Equitable AI in HR: Designing a Fair, Reliable, and Transparent Human Resource Management Application2023
- The digital workplace and its dark side: An integrative reviewComputers in Human Behavior, 2022
- The Janus face of artificial intelligence feedback: Deployment versus disclosure effects on employee performanceStrategic Management Journal, 2021
- Human-machine collaboration in managerial decision makingComputers in Human Behavior, 2021
- On the current state of combining human and artificial intelligence for strategic organizational decision makingBusiness Research, 2020
- Machine learning improves accounting estimates: evidence from insurance paymentsReview of Accounting Studies, 2020
- The Challenges of Algorithm-Based HR Decision-Making for Personal IntegrityJournal of Business Ethics, 2019
- Artificial intelligence and the future of work: Human-AI symbiosis in organizational decision makingBusiness Horizons, 2018
- Understanding how technology paradoxes affect customer satisfaction with self‐service technology: The role of performance ambiguity and trust in technologyPsychology & Marketing, 2008
- Data Mining techniques for the detection of fraudulent financial statementsExpert Systems with Applications, 2007