Do Assessment Tools Shape Policy Preferences? Analysing Policy Framing Effects on Older Adults’ Conceptualisation of Autonomy
Authors:
- Daniel DicksonDDDaniel Dickson
- Patrik MarierPMPatrik Marier
- Anne-Sophie DubéADAnne-Sophie Dubé
- 25 January 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Social Policy
- Vol. 51 (1) , 114-131
Abstract
The concept of autonomy is essential in the practice and study of gerontology and in long-term care policies. For older adults with expanding care needs, scores from tightly specified assessment instruments, which aim to measure the autonomy of service users, usually determine access to social services. These instruments emphasise functional independence in the performance of activities of daily living. In an effort to broaden the understanding of autonomy into needs assessment practice, the province of Québec (Canada) added social and relational elements into the assessment tool. In the wake of these changes, this article studies the interaction between the use of assessment instruments and the extent to which they alter how older adults define their autonomy as service users. This matters since the conceptualisation of autonomy shapes the formulation of long-term care policy problems, influencing both the demand and supply of services and the types of services that ought to be prioritised by governments. Relying on focus groups, this study shows that the functional autonomy frame dominates problem definitions, while social/relational framings are marginal. This reflects the more authoritative weight of functional autonomy within the assessment tool and contributes to the biomedicalisation of aging.Keywords
This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit:
- Transferring Control to OthersJournal of Applied Gerontology, 2013
- ‘Active ageing’: from empty rhetoric to effective policy toolAgeing and Society, 2012
- Relational autonomy in assisted living: A focus on diverse care settings for older adultsJournal of Aging Studies, 2012
- Active ageing: A strategic policy solution to demographic ageing in the European UnionInternational Journal of Social Welfare, 2012
- Validation study of a social functioning scale: The social-SMAF (social-Functional Autonomy Measurement System)Archives of Gerontology and Geriatrics, 2009
- Multidimensional Geriatric Assessment: Back to the Future Second and Third Generation Assessment Instruments: The Birth of Standardization in Geriatric CareThe Journals of Gerontology, Series A: Biological Sciences and Medical Sciences, 2008
- Aspirations for Older Age in the 21st Century: What is Successful Aging?The International Journal of Aging and Human Development, 2007
- Correlates of perceived autonomy among elders in a senior citizen home: A cross-sectional surveyInternational Journal of Nursing Studies, 2006
- Assessment of Older People: Self-Maintaining and Instrumental Activities of Daily LivingThe Gerontologist, 1969
- Studies of Illness in the AgedJAMA, 1963