Comparison of sedative effectiveness of thiopental versus midazolam in reduction of shoulder dislocation
Authors:
- 1 January 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by World Journal of Emergency Medicine in World Journal of Emergency Medicine
- Vol. 9 (2) , 125-129
Abstract
Various sedative drugs have been proposed to control anxiety and agitation in shoulder dislocation, but none of them has been diagnosed as the best sedative and relaxant agent. The study aimed to compare the sedative effectiveness of thiopental versus midazolam in reduction of shoulder dislocation. A randomized double-blind controlled trail was performed in 80 patients with shoulder dislocation recruited from the emergency department. Ten patients were excluded and 70 patients were enrolled in the study. Case group received intravenous thiopental 2 mg/kg+2 µg/kg fentanyl while control group received intravenous midazolam 0.1 mg/kg+2 µg/kg fentanyl. Number of times, patients and physician's satisfaction, difficulty of procedure, degree of muscle relaxation, time of sedation and complete recovery, number of patients with apnea episode, O2 saturation, patient's pain score and adverse events were all recorded. Muscular tone had significant difference between the two groups (P-value=0.014) and thiopental was more muscle relaxant than midazolam. Replacement of shoulder dislocation in thiopental group was easier than midazolam group (P-value=0.043). There was no need to use multiple methods of reduction in either group. Before drug infusion the mean±SD VAS scores were 8.37±2.21 in the midazolam group (A) and 8.94±1.78 in the thiopental group (B); mean difference 0.57, 95% CI= -0.38 to 1.52. After completion of the procedure, the mean±SD VAS scores in group (A) and (B) were 3.20±1.30 vs. 3.65±1.30; mean difference -0.45, 95% CI= -1.07 to 0.16. Thiopental might be more effective and relaxant than midazolam for reduction of shoulder dislocation.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Emergency department procedural sedation for primary electrical cardioversion — a comparison with procedural sedations for other reasonsWorld Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2017
- High‐dose phenobarbital with intermittent short‐acting barbiturates for acute encephalitis with refractory, repetitive partial seizuresPediatrics International, 2016
- Reversible Coma Associated With Prolonged High-Dose Phenobarbital Therapy in Bilateral Sturge-Weber SyndromeJournal of Child Neurology, 2009
- Etomidate and midazolam for procedural sedation: prospective, randomized trialThe American Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2005
- Propofol versus Midazolam/Fentanyl for Reduction of Anterior Shoulder DislocationAcademic Emergency Medicine, 2005
- Etomidate for Procedural Sedation in the Emergency DepartmentAnnals of Pharmacotherapy, 2004
- Etomidate and midazolam for reduction of anterior shoulder dislocation: A randomized, controlled trialAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 2002
- Comparative evaluation of TIVA with propofol-fentanyl and thiopental-sevoflurane anesthesia using laryngeal mask airway for diagnostic bronchoscopyJournal of Anesthesia, 1998
- Anterior shoulder dislocation: A review of reduction techniquesThe American Journal of Emergency Medicine, 1991
- Comparison of Midazolam and Thiopental for Rapid Sequence Anesthetic Induction for Elective Cesarean SectionAnesthesia & Analgesia, 1987