Signals of Efforts or Evidence of Automation? The Countersignaling Effect of Prompt Disclosure
Authors:
- Jiding ZhangJZJiding Zhang
- Che-Wei LiuCLChe-Wei Liu
- Xiaowei LiuXLXiaowei Liu
- Jiang DuanJDJiang Duan
- Mingwei SunMSMingwei Sun
Preprint
- 17 April 2026
- preprint
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract
Transparency has often been regarded as a valuable practice in user-generated content (UGC), where revealing the creative process is thought to enhance perceived authenticity, effort, and credibility. However, in the context of human-AI co-creation, this logic may no longer hold. When generative AI (GenAI) plays a co-creating role in producing content, process-level disclosure-such as revealing the textual prompt used to generate an image-may instead expose the minimal nature of human input, undermining perceptions of creators' efforts and creativity. Drawing on signaling theory and the concept of countersignaling, we examine how prompt visibility affects audience engagement on a major GenAI platform. Analyzing a largescale dataset of user posts, we find that prompt display significantly reduces engagement relative to concealment. Rather than reflecting a uniform transparency effect, this engagement penalty arises because prompt disclosure shifts audience evaluation toward a proportionality-based assessment of creative contribution, in which viewers implicitly compare observable human input with the sophistication of the generated output. Consistent with this logic, transparency is less costly when disclosed prompts make substantial human input salient, but more damaging when highly polished outputs render the revealed input seemingly insufficient. In sum, we find that in AI-mediated creativity, transparency is not uniformly rewarded; its effects depend on how disclosed process information reshapes audience inferences about human contribution. Our findings challenge conventional assumptions about transparency in digital creativity and offer new insights into how audiences evaluate human contribution in AI-mediated content. We discuss implications for creators, platform designers, and researchers navigating attribution, engagement, and disclosure in the GenAI age.Keywords
This publication has 44 references indexed in Scilit:
- The transparency dilemma: How AI disclosure erodes trustOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 2025
- Complementor Value Co-Creation in Generative AI Platform EcosystemsJournal of Management Information Systems, 2025
- Generative AI and its Transformative Value for Digital PlatformsJournal of Management Information Systems, 2025
- AI-generated Content2024
- Insight versus effort. Communicating the creative process leading to new productsInternational Journal of Research in Marketing, 2020
- Robust Inference Using Inverse Probability WeightingJournal of the American Statistical Association, 2019
- The Effort Paradox: Effort Is Both Costly and ValuedTrends in Cognitive Sciences, 2018
- The IKEA effect: When labor leads to loveJournal of Consumer Psychology, 2011
- The Quest for Authenticity in Consumption: Consumers’ Purposive Choice of Authentic Cues to Shape Experienced OutcomesJournal of Consumer Research, 2010
- The processes of causal attribution.American Psychologist, 1973