The section substantiates the methodological principles of forming critical thinking in future lawyers in the process of professional training. Critical thinking is considered as an integrative quality of the personality, which combines cognitive, communicative, reflective and prognostic characteristics and provides the ability to make informed decisions in the legal sphere. The component structure of critical thinking is determined, which includes cognitive-structural, communicative-activity, value-reflective, interpretative-analytical and prognostic-adaptive components. On this basis, a system of criteria and indicators of its formation, differentiated into personal and professional, has been developed, which provides a comprehensive approach to diagnostics. The levels of critical thinking formation (low, medium, sufficient, high) are substantiated, which reflect the dynamics of this quality development in education seekers. The pedagogical conditions for the formation of critical thinking are determined and analyzed, in particular, the use of interactive training tools, the development of self-regulation and emotional stability, as well as the formation of the ability to critically analyze information influences and legal manipulations. The feasibility of using expert ranking to determine the significance of pedagogical conditions is proven and the transdisciplinary approach role in ensuring the integrity of lawyers’ professional training is emphasized. The results obtained can be used to improve educational programs and increase the effectiveness of future lawyers’ training.