Changes in an Insecticide-Resistant Field Population of German Cockroach (Dictyoptera: Blattellidae) After Exposure to an Insecticide Mixture

Authors:

Abstract
Combinations of sticky trap monitoring, toxicity tests, and biochemical assays were conducted to study the effects of an insecticide mixture on an insecticide-resistant field population of the German cockroach, Blattella germanica (L.). Monthly treatments (6 total; months 1-6) were made, the 1st treatment consisted of a formulated pyrethroid insecticide (lambdacyhalothrin) + synergist (piperonyl butoxide) + juvenile hormone analog (pyriproxyfen), and the following 5 consisted of lambdacyhalothrin + pyriproxyfen alone. This study was monitored for 12 mo. We found reductions in sticky trap catches (from 27.9 to 2.6 cockroaches trapped per apartment at the beginning and end of the study, respectively); increases in the percentage of trapped adults having twisted wings (an indicator of juvenile hormone analog-induced sterility); and reduced ratios of nymphs:adults and gravid:nongravid females. For F1 offspring of cockroaches live-trapped before insecticide treatments, topical toxicity tests revealed the following: resistance to the active ingredient used on the population for 8 previous years (cypermethrin; LD50 resistance ratio [RR] = 82.2), a reduction in cypermethrin resistance following pretreatment with piperonyl butoxide (90.2% at LD50), and cross-resistance to chlorpyrifos (LD50 RR = 5.22). In surface-contact (jar) tests, significant tolerance was also found to cypermethrin (LT50 RR = 7.3), chlorpyrifos (LT50 RR = 1.2), and lambdacyhalothrin (LT50 RR = 1.5). In F1 offspring of cockroaches collected from the field after an 80.0% reduction in trap catch, jar tests with lambdacyhalothrin indicated increased tolerance over the original population (25.0% at LT50). Similarly, biochemical assays of hydrolytic and oxidative enzymes indicated increases in 1-naphthyl acetate and 2-naphthyl acetate hydrolysis, and in total cytochrome P450 content, but no change in p -nitrophenyl acetate hydrolysis. We discuss results in terms of the effects of this strategy on resistance levels, suspected resistance mechanisms, and the further development of resistance management strategies.