IS NEWER ALWAYS BETTER? A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF 3 LITHOTRIPTOR GENERATIONS
Authors:
- 1 June 2005
- journal article
- clinical trial
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Journal of Urology
- Vol. 173 (6) , 2013-2016
Abstract
At a single center we compared the efficacy of 3 generations of lithotriptors using identical protocol inclusion and followup criteria but with different modes of anesthesia.We compared stone disintegration and dilatation of the pyelocaliceal system achieved in a prospective, randomized trial comparing the original HM3 (Dornier Medtech, Kennesaw, Georgia) and Lithostar Plus (LSP) lithotriptors, and a matched, consecutive series of 107 treatments with the Modulith SLX. Stone disintegration and dilatation of the pyelocaliceal system were evaluated by abdominal plain x-ray and renal ultrasonography 1 day and 3 months after treatment.A total of 82 treatments with the HM3, 75 with the LSP and 107 with the SLX were analyzed, matched for stone burden and location within the pyelocaliceal system. On postoperative day 1, 91%, 65% and 48% patients treated with the HM3, LSP and SLX, respectively, were stone-free or had fragments that were 2 mm or less (HM3 vs LSP p <0.001, HM3 vs SLX p <0.001 and LSP vs SLX p = 0.015). Three to 5 mm fragments were found in 7%, 21% and 35% of patients (p = 0.006, <0.001 and 0.06), and fragments 6 mm or greater were found in 1%, 14% and 15% (p = 0.002, <0.001 and 0.1, respectively). The re-treatment rate was 4% in the HM3 group, 13% in the LSP group and 38% in the SLX group (HM3 vs LSP p = 0.05, HM3 vs SLX p <0.001 and LSP vs SLX p <0.001). Obstructive pyelonephritis occurred in 1% of the HM3 group, 8% of the LSP group and 5% of the SLX group (HM3 vs LSP p = 0.02, HM3 vs SLX p = 0.12 and LSP vs SLX p = 0.4). All re-treatments except those in 5 patients were performed with the HM3. Therefore, the 3-month stone-free rate was comparable in all 3 groups (HM3 87%, LSP 80% and SLX 81%).This study indicates that the HM3 lithotriptor disintegrates caliceal and renal pelvic stones better than the LSP and SLX machines, resulting in fewer complications and re-treatments. Disintegration with the LSP machine was also superior to that of the SLX with a need for fewer re-treatments.Keywords
This publication has 12 references indexed in Scilit:
- A Prospective Randomized Trial Comparing 2 Lithotriptors for Stone Disintegration and Induced Renal TraumaJournal of Urology, 2003
- First clinical experience with extracorporeally induced destruction of kidney stones by shock wavesJournal of Urology, 2002
- EXTRACORPOREAL SHOCK-WAVE LITHOTRIPSY: A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF ELECTROHYDRAULIC AND ELECTROMAGNETIC UNITSJournal of Urology, 2001
- The mechanisms of stone fragmentation in ESWLUltrasound in Medicine & Biology, 2001
- IN VITRO COMPARISON OF SHOCK WAVE LITHOTRIPSY MACHINESJournal of Urology, 2000
- Extracorporeal Shockwave Lithotripsy of 2000 Urinary Calculi with the Modulith SL-20: Success and Failure According to Size and Location of StonesJournal of Endourology, 2000
- Mechanisms of Differing Stone Fragility in Extracorporeal Shockwave Lithotripsy*Journal of Endourology, 1994
- The mechanisms of stone disintegration by shock wavesUltrasound in Medicine & Biology, 1991
- Calculation of Stone Volume and Urinary Stone Staging with Computer AssistanceJournal of Endourology, 1989
- Extracorporeal Shock Wave Lithotripsy: The Methodist Hospital of Indiana ExperienceJournal of Urology, 1986