Building Footprint Extraction from Classified TLS Point Clouds: Evaluation of Point Cloud Cleaning Methods
Open Access
Abstract
Terrestrial laser scanning (TLS) represents an efficient method for acquiring spatial data in urban environments, while the quality of resulting geometric outputs is significantly influenced by subsequent point cloud processing. This article focuses on analyzing the accuracy of automatic building footprint extraction from classified TLS point clouds, with an emphasis on the role of data cleaning methods. The study area is located in the city center of Žiar nad Hronom, where urban structures were monitored using TLS. For detailed analysis, three objects were selected—an apartment building, a garage, and an industrial building—representing different levels of geometric complexity. To simulate realistic processing conditions, classification results obtained from different software (Leica Cyclone 3DR, Trimble RealWorks, and LiDAR360) were used. Their quality was evaluated using standard metrics such as Precision, Recall, and F1-score. These classifications also served as input scenarios containing typical errors, such as point clusters, vegetation near buildings, or misclassified terrain elements. Subsequently, selected point cloud cleaning methods were applied to these datasets, specifically statistical outlier removal, noise filter, and label connected components. The accuracy of the extracted building footprints was evaluated by comparison with reference data obtained from geodetic measurements. The results show that automatic classification alone is not sufficient to achieve accurate building footprints, and that data cleaning plays a decisive role. For example, in the case of the apartment building, statistical filtering reduced the area from 1052 m2 to approximately 854 m2 (reference value: 706 m2) and significantly improved positional accuracy (centroid shift reduced from 0.455 m to 0.077 m). Similarly, for the industrial building, the area was reduced from 215 m2 to approximately 165 m2 (reference: 148 m2) while maintaining the correct number of corner points. In contrast, noise filter method proved to be less reliable, as removing up to 25–30% of points often did not lead to improvements in footprint geometry. The results highlight the importance of systematic point cloud cleaning as a key step in automated building footprint extraction and demonstrate that a properly selected combination of methods can significantly improve accuracy even in noisy datasets. The article also provides practical guidance for efficient TLS data processing in geoinformatics applications.Keywords
Funding Information
- Kultúrna a Edukacná Grantová Agentúra MŠVVaŠ SR (018TUKE-4/2026)
- Kultúrna a Edukacná Grantová Agentúra MŠVVaŠ SR (011TUKE-4/2024)
- Agentúra na Podporu Výskumu a Vývoja (APVV-18-0351)
- Interreg (HUSK/2302/1.2/060)
This publication has 37 references indexed in Scilit:
- Comparative analysis of different machine learning algorithms for urban footprint extraction in diverse urban contexts using high-resolution remote sensing imageryJournal of Geographical Sciences, 2025
- Scanning the underground: Comparison of the accuracies of SLAM and static laser scanners in a mine tunnelMeasurement, 2024
- A comprehensive overview of deep learning techniques for 3D point cloud classification and semantic segmentationMachine Vision and Applications, 2024
- HD-Net: High-resolution decoupled network for building footprint extraction via deeply supervised body and boundary decompositionISPRS Journal of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, 2024
- Automatic building footprint extraction from photogrammetric and LiDAR point clouds using a novel improved-Octree approachJournal of Building Engineering, 2023
- PH-shape: an adaptive persistent homology-based approach for building outline extraction from ALS point cloud dataGeo-spatial Information Science, 2023
- Building footprint extraction from aerial photogrammetric point cloud data using its geometric featuresJournal of Building Engineering, 2023
- Application of combined terrestrial laser scanning and unmanned aerial vehicle digital photogrammetry method in high rock slope stability analysis: A case studyMeasurement, 2022
- Determination of underground mining-induced displacement field using multi-temporal TLS point cloud registrationMeasurement, 2021
- A rasterized building footprint dataset for the United StatesScientific Data, 2020