Evaluation of Two Appropriateness Criteria for Total Knee Replacement
Open Access
- 25 June 2014
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Arthritis Care & Research
- Vol. 66 (11) , 1749-1753
Abstract
Objective: Insurance expansion under the Affordable Care Act will amplify a projected 6‐fold increase in total knee replacement (TKR) utilization by 2030 but will not fully address TKR disparities. Promoting appropriate use of TKR would help reduce disparities and improve outcomes. There are currently no validated appropriateness criteria (AC) for TKR in the US. We evaluated the performance of 2 non‐US AC in a cohort of US TKR patients.Methods: AC1 was developed in Spain using the modified Delphi method with 624 patient scenarios. AC2 was developed in Canada using the overall Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index score of ≥39 as the cutoff point for surgery. These criteria were applied to a random sample of TKR patients enrolled in our institutional registry. Preoperative clinical, radiographic, and patient‐reported survey data were used in classifying patients. The rate of appropriateness was compared for the 2 AC. Inappropriate cases were further investigated to determine other mitigating factors beyond the criteria influencing the decision to operate.Results: In total, 508 TKR procedures were evaluated. All patients had osteoarthritic radiographic changes. On the basis of AC1, 7.7% of cases were classified as inappropriate and 11.6% uncertain. On the basis of AC2, 31.5% were classified as inappropriate. Only 4.7% of the cases were classified as inappropriate by both ACs; however, there was poor agreement between the 2 AC (κ = −0.08). Beyond the criteria, failure of nonsurgical treatment and clinically significant valgus/varus deformities influenced the decision for surgery.Conclusion: There was poor agreement between 2 validated AC for TKR when tested in a US population. Culturally specific AC are needed to promote rational use of TKR.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Institute of Child Health and Human Development (r00 hd060686)
- Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (u18 hs016075)
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- Appropriateness Criteria and Elective Procedures — Total Joint ArthroplastyNew England Journal of Medicine, 2012
- The appropriateness method has acceptable reliability and validity for assessing overuse and underuse of surgical proceduresJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2012
- Evidence Of No Benefit From Knee Surgery For Osteoarthritis Led To Coverage Changes And Is Linked To Decline In ProceduresHealth Affairs, 2012
- Rationing of total knee replacement: a cost-effectiveness analysis on a large trial data setBMJ Open, 2012
- Who should have a joint replacement? A plea for more ‘phronesis’Osteoarthritis and Cartilage, 2011
- The role of pain and functional impairment in the decision to recommend total joint replacement in hip and knee osteoarthritis: an international cross-sectional study of 1909 patients. Report of the OARSI-OMERACT Task Force on total joint replacementOsteoarthritis and Cartilage, 2011
- Development and preliminary psychometric testing of a new OA pain measure – an OARSI/OMERACT initiativeOsteoarthritis and Cartilage, 2008
- Agreement about Indications for Total Knee ArthroplastyClinical Orthopaedics and Related Research, 2006
- Development and Validation of a Lower-Extremity Activity ScaleJournal of Bone and Joint Surgery, 2005
- The New Zealand priority criteria project. Part 1: OverviewBMJ, 1997