The Influence of Peer Review on the Research Assessment Exercise
- 1 August 2004
- journal article
- review article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Information Science
- Vol. 30 (4) , 347-368
Abstract
The use of peer review within both the scholarly communication system and the UK’s Research Assessment Exercise is reviewed. The common denominator is that of peer-reviewed academic journals, since peer review is used by referees to aid publication decisions and by RAE panel members to evaluate a department’s research performance. We propose that since academic research is now subject to peer review at all stages of evaluation, it is becoming an accepted method of rewarding (by funding) research. The growth of electronic publications (both toll-access and open access) provides possibilities for changes to some of the process of peer review and RAE, but the fundamental model of peer review to reduce the number of poor quality publications will remain. The paper concludes that because of the many criticisms of peer review, it is unwise to base funding decisions on second level peer review of articles that have already undergone peer review.Keywords
This publication has 39 references indexed in Scilit:
- Quality and the research assessment exercise: just one aspect of performance?Quality Assurance in Education, 2001
- A critical review of the application of citation studies to the Research Assessment ExercisesJournal of Information Science, 2000
- Project update: Electronic submission and peer review — an update on the ESPERE projectLearned Publishing, 1997
- Research on research evaluationSocial Epistemology, 1996
- Electronic journals and legitimate media in the systems of scholarly communicationThe Information Society, 1995
- British library and information science journals: a study of quality controlJournal of Information Science, 1995
- Publishing International Business Research: A Survey of Leading JournalsJournal of International Business Studies, 1995
- Peer Review: A Vital IngredientSerials, 1991
- Errors in Bibliographic Citations: A Continuing ProblemThe Library Quarterly, 1989
- Norms and functions in citation: The view of journal editors and referees in psychologySocial Science Information Studies, 1982