Health and Surgical Outcomes in Canada and the United States

Authors:
  • EFElliott S. Fisher
    Elliott S. Fisher
  • RBRuth Brazauskas
    Ruth Brazauskas
  • SSSandra M. Sharp
    Sandra M. Sharp
  • ESEvelyn Shapiro
    Evelyn Shapiro

Abstract
Prologue: The health care system of every nation bears its own unique signature. Three decades ago, the systems operating in Canada and the United States were quite similar—reflecting in part our common culture and, for the most part, common language. Since then, Canada's provinces created publicly financed health insurance plans that provide universal coverage while constraining spending and largely protecting the clinical autonomy of physicians. Divergence of the two systems reflects the values that underlie the two societies, including Canadas greater willingness to entrust health financing to government. One dimension of the two systems that has not been thoroughly compared is how patients fare when they seek treatment for similar conditions. The Bush health plan misinterpreted earlier research on surgical outcomes in New England and Manitoba, emphasizing that “post-operative mortality … is 44 percent higher in Canada than in the United States for high-risk procedures.” As this paper shows, much of th...

This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit: