Guilty But Good: Defending Voluntary Active Euthanasia From a Virtue Perspective
- 1 July 2008
- journal article
- other
- Published by SAGE Publications in Nursing Ethics
- Vol. 15 (4) , 434-445
Abstract
This article is presented as a defence of voluntary active euthanasia from a virtue perspective and it is written with the objective of generating debate and challenging the assumption that killing is necessarily vicious in all circumstances. Practitioners are often torn between acting from virtue and acting from duty. In the case presented the physician was governed by compassion and this illustrates how good people may have the courage to sacrifice their own security in the interests of virtue. The doctor's action created huge tensions for the nurse, who was governed by the code of conduct and relevant laws. Appraising active euthanasia from a virtue perspective can offer a more compassionate approach to the predicament of practitioners and clients. The tensions arising from the virtue versus rules debate generates irreconcilable difficulties for nurses. A shift towards virtue would help to resolve this problem and support the call for a change in the law. The controversial nature of this position is acknowledged. The argument is put forward on the understanding that many practitioners will not agree with the conclusions reached.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Acts, omissions, intentions and motives: a philosophical examination of the moral distinction between killing and letting dieJournal of Advanced Nursing, 1998
- Beneficent Voluntary Active Euthanasia: a challenge to professionals caring for terminally ill patientsNursing Ethics, 1998
- What are the limits to the obligations of the nurse?Journal of Medical Ethics, 1996
- After Kohlberg: Virtue ethics and the recovery of the moral selfPhilosophical Psychology, 1996
- NewsBMJ, 1992
- NewsBMJ, 1992
- Medicine and the Law: Call for inquiry into ambulance directiveThe Lancet, 1992
- On De-Kantianizing the perfectly moral personThe Journal of Value Inquiry, 1983
- The Tyranny of PrinciplesHastings Center Report, 1981
- Virtue and ReasonThe Monist, 1979