Representing Multidimensional Phenomena of Geographic Interest: Benefit of the Doubt or Principal Component Analysis?
- 2 May 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Professional Geographer
- Vol. 74 (4) , 758-771
Abstract
Composite indicators are one-dimensional measures of multidimensional phenomena. Through the composite indicators, it is possible to have a single map of the different subindicators of poverty, inequality, sustainability, and economic development. This research employs two well-known methods of building composite indicators to represent the social exclusion of eight cities. This research shows that the benefit of the doubt and principal component analysis have limitations to representing multidimensional phenomena of geographic interest, but adaptations in these methods reduce these limitations. The benefit of the doubt constrained (BoD-c) restricts subindicator weight variations, increasing the composite indicator’s capacity to represent the most important subindicator in the concept of the multidimensional phenomenon. The principal component analysis adjusted (PCA-a) discards poorly correlated subindicators, ensuring a variance extracted in the first component above the acceptance threshold of 0.50. Contrasting BoD-c and PCA-a, geographically weighted principal component analysis has a limited capacity to capture the most important subindicator in the concept of the multidimensional phenomenon. Among twenty-three experts from nine countries, eighteen preferred PCA-a to BoD-c, indicating that information loss is not as critical a property as full comparability across geographic areas. Local experts agree that both maps represent local social reality, but PCA-a is more faithful to that reality.Keywords
Funding Information
- Coordination for the Improvement of Personnel in Higher Education–Brasil
- National Scientific and Technological Development of Brazil (43/, -0, 32/, -8)
This publication has 51 references indexed in Scilit:
- Geographically weighted principal components analysisInternational Journal of Geographical Information Science, 2011
- INCOME POVERTY AND MULTIDIMENSIONAL DEPRIVATION: LESSONS FROM CROSS‐REGIONAL ANALYSISReview of Income and Wealth, 2011
- Social exclusion of older people in deprived urban communities of EnglandEuropean Journal of Ageing, 2005
- Labor Market Marginalization of Youth in San Antonio, TexasThe Professional Geographer, 2000
- Data Envelopment Analysis Theory, Methodology and ApplicationsJournal of the Operational Research Society, 1997
- The Proof and Measurement of Association between Two ThingsThe American Journal of Psychology, 1987
- Determining the Number of Components from the Matrix of Partial CorrelationsPsychometrika, 1976
- Little Jiffy, Mark IvEducational and Psychological Measurement, 1974
- Discarding Variables in a Principal Component Analysis. II: Real DataJournal of the Royal Statistical Society Series C: Applied Statistics, 1973
- Discarding Variables in a Principal Component Analysis. I: Artificial DataJournal of the Royal Statistical Society Series C: Applied Statistics, 1972