What makes on-farm experimental data suitable for data-driven decision-making? Implications of trial design and spatial distribution of field data for machine learning models
Open Access
- 20 September 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Precision Agriculture
- Vol. 26 (5) , 1-23
Abstract
Purpose: On-farm experimentation (OFE) plays a key role in underpinning data-driven agronomic decision-making. For example, machine learning (ML) models can predict optimal nitrogen (N) fertiliser rates using trial crop responses alongside soil, plant, and climatic data. However, it is unclear how different OFE strategies, trial designs, and their consequences for the spatial distribution of field datasets, impact the development of such models. This work sought to investigate how trial design influences spatial autocorrelation in OFE data and the impact of this on model training. It was also of interest to explore whether tailoring OFE programs and ML models to specific regions might improve their performance compared to those generated for large geographic areas. Methods: Using 21 N strip trials across Australia, ML models were developed to predict optimal N rates under different scenarios of data autocorrelation and geographic coverage. Results: Spatial autocorrelation in OFE data had negligible impact on model performance. At the same time, models trained with fewer non-correlated observations showed similar performance to models trained with thousands of autocorrelated observations. This suggests that less replicated field trials providing more independent observations might be preferable – for their simplicity and pragmatism – to highly replicated, whole-field trials which generate highly autocorrelated field data. The results also indicate that regional models may perform better than global models. Conclusion: Overall, to improve both the quantity and quality of OFE data for ML models used to underpin a mid-season N fertiliser decision, prioritising a greater number of simpler experiments (less replicated strip or plot trials) across a region is likely to be more effective than increasing field coverage of individual experiments using highly replicated whole-field designs focused on field-specific models.Keywords
Funding Information
- Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation
This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- A new method to compare treatments in unreplicated on-farm experimentationPrecision Agriculture, 2024
- Can machine learning models provide accurate fertilizer recommendations?Precision Agriculture, 2024
- Digital strategies for nitrogen management in grain production systems: lessons from multi-method assessment using on-farm experimentationPrecision Agriculture, 2024
- Predicting site-specific economic optimal nitrogen rate using machine learning methods and on-farm precision experimentationPrecision Agriculture, 2023
- An efficient geostatistical analysis tool for on-farm experiments targeted at localised treatmentBiosystems Engineering, 2021
- Economic viability, energy and nutrient balances of site-specific fertilisation for citrusBiosystems Engineering, 2020
- Spatial variability of crop responses to agronomic inputs in on-farm precision experimentationPrecision Agriculture, 2020
- The value of conducting on-farm field trials using precision agriculture technology: a theory and simulationsPrecision Agriculture, 2020
- Machine learning approaches for crop yield prediction and nitrogen status estimation in precision agriculture: A reviewComputers and Electronics in Agriculture, 2018
- Statistics for Spatial Data1993