A Multicenter Evaluation of a Closed-Loop Anesthesia Delivery System
Authors:
- Goverdhan D. PuriGPGoverdhan D. Puri
- Preethy J. MathewPMPreethy J. Mathew
- Indranil BiswasIBIndranil Biswas
- Amitabh DuttaADAmitabh Dutta
- Jayashree SoodJSJayashree Sood
- Satinder GombarSGSatinder Gombar
- Sanjeev PaltaSPSanjeev Palta
- Morup TseringMTMorup Tsering
- P. L. GautamPGP. L. Gautam
- Aveek JayantAJAveek Jayant
- Inderjeet AroraIAInderjeet Arora
- Vishal BajajVBVishal Bajaj
- 1 January 2016
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Anesthesia & Analgesia
- Vol. 122 (1) , 106-114
Abstract
Closed-loop systems for anesthesia delivery have been shown to outperform traditional manual control in different clinical settings. The present trial was aimed at evaluating the feasibility and efficacy of Bispectral Index (BIS)-guided closed-loop anesthesia delivery system (CLADS) in comparison with manual control across multiple centers in India. Adult patients scheduled for major surgical procedures of an expected duration of 1 to 3 hours were randomized across 6 sites into 2 groups: a CLADS group and a manual group. In the manual control group, propofol infusion was titrated manually by the attending anesthesiologist to a BIS of 50 during induction and maintenance. Analgesia was maintained with fentanyl infusion and nitrous oxide in both groups. In the CLADS group, both induction and maintenance of anesthesia were performed automatically using CLADS. The primary outcome measure was the performance of the system as assessed by the percentage of total anesthesia time BIS remained ±10 of target BIS. The secondary outcome measures were a percentage of anesthesia-time heart rate and mean arterial pressure within 25% of the baseline, median absolute performance error, wobble, and global score. Wobble indicates intraindividual variability in the control of BIS, and global score reflects the overall performance; lower values indicate superior performance for both parameters. The performance parameters of the system also were compared among the participating sites. Two hundred forty-two patients were randomized. BIS was maintained within ±10 of target for significantly longer time in the CLADS group (81.4% ± 8.9 % of anesthesia duration) than in the manual group (55.34% ± 25%, P < 0.0001). The indices that assess performance were significantly better in the CLADS group than the manual group as follows: median absolute performance error was 10 (10, 12) (median [interquartile range]) in the CLADS group versus 18 (14, 24) in the manual group, P < 0.0001; wobble was 9 (8, 10) in CLADS group versus 10 (8, 14) in the manual group, P = 0.0009; and Global score, which reflects overall performance, was 24 (19, 30) in the CLADS group versus 51 (31, 99) in the manual group, P < 0.0001. The percentage of time heart rate was within 25% of the baseline was significantly greater in the CLADS group (heart rate of 95 [87, 99], median [interquartile range], in the CLADS group versus 90 [75, 98] in the manual group P = 0.0031). On comparison of data between the centers, the performance parameters did not differ significantly among the centers in the CLADS group (P = 0.94), but the parameters differed significantly among the centers in the manual group (P < 0.001). Our study in a multicenter setting proves the consistently better performance of automated anesthesia drug delivery compared with conventional manual control. This highlights an important advantage of an automated system for delivering standardized anesthesia, thereby overcoming differences in practices among anesthesiologists.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Feasibility of Closed-loop Titration of Propofol and Remifentanil Guided by the Spectral M-Entropy MonitorAnesthesiology, 2012
- Closed loop anaesthesia at high altitude (3505 m above sea level): Performance characteristics of an indigenously developed closed loop anaesthesia delivery systemIndian Journal of Anaesthesia, 2012
- Bispectral index-controlled postoperative sedation in cardiac surgery patients: a comparative trial between closed loop and manual administration of propofolEuropean Journal of Anaesthesiology, 2010
- Comparison of closed loop vs. manual administration of propofol using the Bispectral index in cardiac surgeryActa Anaesthesiologica Scandinavica, 2009
- Propofol–fentanyl anaesthesia at high altitude: anaesthetic requirements and haemodynamic variations when compared with anaesthesia at low altitudeActa Anaesthesiologica Scandinavica, 2008
- Feasibility of closed-loop titration of propofol guided by the Bispectral Index for general anaesthesia inductionEuropean Journal of Anaesthesiology, 2006
- Titration of Propofol for Anesthetic Induction and Maintenance Guided by the Bispectral Index: Closed-loop versus Manual ControlAnesthesiology, 2006
- Measuring the predictive performance of computer-controlled infusion pumpsJournal of Pharmacokinetics and Biopharmaceutics, 1992
- The Hawthorne Experiments: First Statistical InterpretationAmerican Sociological Review, 1978
- THE CLINICAL APPLICATION OF AUTOMATIC ANESTHESIAAnesthesiology, 1951