Methodological Concerns and Quality Appraisal of Contemporary Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses in Pediatric Urology
Authors:
- 1 July 2011
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Journal of Urology
- Vol. 186 (1) , 266-272
Abstract
The usefulness of systematic reviews and meta-analyses in influencing clinical practice depends on their quality. We sought to analyze the quality of published systematic reviews and meta-analyses in pediatric urology. We searched PubMed (MEDLINE) and Embase for all systematic reviews and meta-analyses published in the top 5 pediatric urology journals between January 2000 and November 2009. Two reviewers independently selected articles for full text review. Scientific methodological quality was evaluated using the Assessment of Multiple Systematic Reviews 11-item tool. Of 267 initial results 220 articles were excluded because they were surveys, case reports or narrative reviews. Full text evaluation of the remaining 47 articles further excluded 32 series of exclusively adult patients, leaving 15 for final analysis. Seven articles (47%) were published in 2009 (p <0.01). Only 1 review (7%) described a full search strategy and 3 (20%) allowed inclusion of non-English studies. In 8 reviews (53%) selection of studies was performed by 2 reviewers. Five systematic reviews (33%) described some form of quality assessment. Only 5 reviews (33%) described assessment of publication bias, while 8 (53%) checked for heterogeneity among studies. According to AMSTAR criteria, 7 systematic reviews (47%) were considered of less than fair methodological quality, 5 (33%) fair to good quality and 3 (20%) good quality. Despite a recent increase in the number of systematic reviews and meta-analyses published in pediatric urology journals, almost half of these reviews lack good scientific quality, raising concerns about their role in influencing clinical practice. Efforts should be made to improve the methodological quality of systematic reviews and meta-analyses in the pediatric urology literature.Keywords
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- AMSTAR is a reliable and valid measurement tool to assess the methodological quality of systematic reviewsJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2009
- Incidence of Post-Pyelonephritic Renal Scarring: A Meta-Analysis of the Dimercapto-Succinic Acid LiteratureJournal of Urology, 2009
- Scintigraphic renal function after unilateral pyeloplasty in children: a systematic reviewBJU International, 2008
- Botulinum Toxin Injections for Neurogenic and Idiopathic Detrusor Overactivity: A Critical Analysis of ResultsEuropean Urology, 2006
- A Meta-Analysis of Surgical Practice Patterns in the Endoscopic Management of UreterocelesJournal of Urology, 2006
- Endoscopic Therapy for Vesicoureteral Reflux: A Meta-Analysis. I. Reflux Resolution and Urinary Tract InfectionJournal of Urology, 2006
- Treatment of Daytime Urinary Incontinence in Children: A Systematic Review of Randomized Controlled TrialsJournal of Urology, 2003
- Etiology Of Spontaneous Perirenal Hemorrhage: A Meta-AnalysisJournal of Urology, 2002
- Bias in meta-analytic researchJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 1992
- Validation of an index of the quality of review articlesJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 1991