Combining systems thinking approaches and implementation science constructs within community-based prevention: a systematic review
Authors:
Open Access
- 28 August 2023
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Springer Nature in Health Research Policy and Systems
- Vol. 21 (1) , 1-15
Abstract
Background: Systems science offers methods for designing population health interventions while implementation science provides specific guidance for successful implementation. Integrating systems and implementation science may strengthen implementation and enhance and sustain systemic change to achieve system-level outcomes. Little is known about the extent to which these two approaches have been integrated to date. This review aimed to identify and synthesise the peer-reviewed literature that has reported the combined use of systems thinking approaches and implementation science constructs (within the same study), to deliver population health interventions. Methods: A systematic literature search of peer-reviewed original research was conducted across six databases from 2009 to 2021. Journal manuscripts were included if they: (1) reported on a population health study conducted in a community, (2) reported the use of a systems method in the design of the intervention, and (3) used an implementation science theory, framework or model in the delivery of the intervention. Data extracted related to the specific systems methods and definitions and implementation science constructs used. The Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT) was used to assess study quality. Results: Of the 9086 manuscripts returned, 320 manuscripts were included for full-text review. Of these, 17 manuscripts that reported on 14 studies were included in the final extraction. The most frequently reported systems methods were a ‘whole of community systems approach’ (n = 4/14) and ‘community-based system dynamics’ (n = 2/14). Nineteen different implementation science theories, frameworks and models were used for intervention delivery, with RE-AIM being the only framework used in more than one study. Conclusion: There are few published peer-reviewed studies using systems thinking and implementation science for designing and delivering population health interventions. An exploration of synergies is worthwhile to operationalise alignment and improve implementation of systems thinking approaches. Review protocol registration PROSPERO CRD42021250419.Keywords
Funding Information
- Deakin University
- National Health and Medical Research Council (1152968, 1151572)
This publication has 66 references indexed in Scilit:
- Systematic review of the application of the plan–do–study–act method to improve quality in healthcareBMJ Quality & Safety, 2013
- San Diego Healthy Weight Collaborative: A Systems Approach to Address Childhood ObesityJournal Of Health Care For The Poor and Underserved, 2013
- Systems Science Methods in Public Health: Dynamics, Networks, and AgentsAnnual Review of Public Health, 2012
- Effectiveness-implementation Hybrid DesignsMedical Care, 2012
- Phases of school health promotion implementation through the lens of complexity theory: lessons learnt from an Austrian case studyHealth Promotion International, 2010
- Implementing a social‐ecological model of health in WalesHealth Education, 2010
- Places to Intervene to Make Complex Food Systems More Healthy, Green, Fair, and AffordableJournal of Hunger & Environmental Nutrition, 2009
- Integrative system dynamics: analysis of policy options for tobacco control in New ZealandSystems Research and Behavioral Science, 2008
- Interdisciplinarity and Systems Science to Improve Population HealthAmerican Journal of Preventive Medicine, 2008
- Executive Summary: FORESIGHT ‘Tackling Obesities: Future Choices’ projectObesity Reviews, 2007