The History Manifesto: A Critique

Authors:
  • DCDeborah Cohen
    Deborah Cohen
  • PMPeter Mandler
    Peter Mandler

Abstract
It is probably in the nature of manifestos to be one-eyed and just a little authoritarian: they are rallying cries to lead soldiers into battle. For that reason, history is a subject almost uniquely ill-suited to manifestos. Historians are not soldiers; they don't fight on a single front, and—at a time when, more than ever before, historians have been operating in an impressive diversity of modes and theaters—they certainly don't need to be led in one direction. In our critique, we do not dispute the validity of Guldi and Armitage's favored modes of historiography.1 We have both worked in a variety of time scales (long, short, and medium). We view quantitative and digital methods as useful tools in the historian's repertoire and use them in our own practice (as well as in this critique).2 We are entirely in favor...