Prioritization strategies in clinical practice guidelines development: a pilot study
Open Access
- 6 March 2010
- journal article
- Published by Springer Nature in Health Research Policy and Systems
- Vol. 8 (1) , 7
Abstract
Few methodological studies address the prioritization of clinical topics for the development of Clinical Practice Guidelines (CPGs). The aim of this study was to validate a methodology for Priority Determination of Topics (PDT) of CPGs. Firstly, we developed an instrument for PDT with 41 criteria that were grouped under 10 domains, based on a comprehensive systematic search. Secondly, we performed a survey of stakeholders involved in CPGs development, and end users of guidelines, using the instrument. Thirdly, a pilot testing of the PDT procedure was performed in order to choose 10 guideline topics among 34 proposed projects; using a multi-criteria analysis approach, we validated a mechanism that followed five stages: determination of the composition of groups, item/domain scoring, weights determination, quality of the information used to support judgments, and finally, topic selection. Participants first scored the importance of each domain, after which four different weighting procedures were calculated (including the survey results). The process of weighting was determined by correlating the data between them. We also reported the quality of evidence used for PDT. Finally, we provided a qualitative analysis of the process. The main domains used to support judgement, having higher quality scores and weightings, were feasibility, disease burden, implementation and information needs. Other important domains such as user preferences, adverse events, potential for health promotion, social effects, and economic impact had lower relevance for clinicians. Criteria for prioritization were mainly judged through professional experience, while good quality information was only used in 15% of cases. The main advantages of the proposed methodology are supported by the use of a systematic approach to identify, score and weight guideline topics selection, limiting or exposing the influence of personal biases. However, the methodology was complex and included a number of quantitative and qualitative approaches reflecting the difficulties of the prioritization process.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Prioritizing guideline topics: development and evaluation of a practical toolJournal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, 2007
- Improving the use of research evidence in guideline development: 2. Priority settingHealth Research Policy and Systems, 2006
- Improving the use of research evidence in guideline development: 3. Group composition and consultation processHealth Research Policy and Systems, 2006
- Internet Versus Mailed Questionnaires: A Controlled Comparison (2)Journal of Medical Internet Research, 2004
- Methodological rigour within a qualitative frameworkJournal of Advanced Nursing, 2004
- A pilot study on the use of decision theory and value of information analysis as part of the NHS Health Technology Assessment programmeHealth Technology Assessment, 2004
- An experimental study of determinants of group judgments in clinical guideline developmentThe Lancet, 2004
- Effect of Specialty and Nationality on Panel Judgments of the Appropriateness of Coronary RevascularizationMedical Care, 2001
- Qualitative research in health care: Analysing qualitative dataBMJ, 2000
- How Many Subjects?Journal of Marketing Research, 1989