Validity of the bereavement exclusion to major depression: does the empirical evidence support the proposal to eliminate the exclusion in DSM‐5?
Authors:
- Jerome C. WakefieldJWJerome C. Wakefield
- Michael B. FirstMFMichael B. First
- 1 February 2012
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in World Psychiatry
- Vol. 11 (1) , 3-10
Abstract
The DSM-IV major depression "bereavement exclusion" (BE), which recognizes that depressive symptoms are sometimes normal in recently bereaved individuals, is proposed for elimination in DSM-5. Evidence cited for the BE's invalidity comes from two 2007 reviews purporting to show that bereavement-related depression is similar to other depression across various validators, and a 2010 review of subsequent research. We examined whether the 2007 and 2010 reviews and subsequent relevant literature support the BE's invalidity. Findings were: a) studies included in the 2007 reviews sampled bereavement-related depression groups most of whom were not BE-excluded, making them irrelevant for evaluating BE validity; b) three subsequent studies cited by the 2010 review as supporting BE elimination did examine BE-excluded cases but were in fact inconclusive; and c) two more recent articles comparing recurrence of BE-excluded and other major depressive disorder cases both support the BE's validity. We conclude that the claimed evidence for the BE's invalidity does not exist. The evidence in fact supports the BE's validity and its retention in DSM-5 to prevent false positive diagnoses. We suggest some improvements to increase validity and mitigate risk of false negatives.Keywords
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- Recurrence of Depression After Bereavement-Related DepressionJournal of Nervous & Mental Disease, 2012
- Relation between duration and severity in bereavement‐related depressionActa Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 2011
- Did Narrowing the Major Depression Bereavement Exclusion From DSM-III-R to DSM-IV Increase Validity?Journal of Nervous & Mental Disease, 2011
- Complicated grief and related bereavement issues for DSM-5Depression and Anxiety, 2011
- IsDSM-IVBereavement Exclusion for Major Depression Relevant to Treatment Response?The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry, 2010
- Depression and the pitfalls of causality: Implications for DSM-VJournal of Affective Disorders, 2009
- Is DSM-IV Bereavement Exclusion for Major Depressive Episode Relevant to Severity and Pattern of Symptoms?The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry, 2009
- Drs. Kendler and Zisook ReplyAmerican Journal of Psychiatry, 2009
- Bereavement related and non-bereavement related depressions: A comparative field studyJournal of Affective Disorders, 2009
- Does Bereavement-Related Major Depression Differ From Major Depression Associated With Other Stressful Life Events?American Journal of Psychiatry, 2008