Critical examination of approximate LCAOMO methods. I. Reasons for the failure of the CNDO and INDO methods in theoretical conformational analysis of conjugated compounds
Authors:
- 1 May 1982
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in International Journal of Quantum Chemistry
- Vol. 21 (5) , 833-843
Abstract
It is well known that the CNDO and INDO methods fail in the field of theoretical conformational analysis of conjugated compounds. The NDDO approximation, however, can be applied very successfully to this problem. In this paper, a comparative analysis of these three approximations is performed to clarify the reasons for the failure of the former two methods. It is shown that the defects are inherent in their formalisms, and there is no reasonable possibility to compensate them (e.g., by reparametrization) at the level of the CNDO and INDO approximations. The central inadequacy is the oversimplified treatment of the two‐center exchange interaction. In the case of molecules containing heteroatoms with lone‐pair electrons the known defects concerning the description of Coulombic interactions of anisotropic charge distributions can additionally influence the results. To overcome these shortcomings, at least an extension of the formalism to the level of the NDDO method is necessary.Keywords
This publication has 38 references indexed in Scilit:
- A semiempirical model for the two-center repulsion integrals in the NDDO approximationTheoretical Chemistry Accounts, 1977
- Concerning the Conformation of Isolated BenzylideneanilineHelvetica Chimica Acta, 1976
- Cis-trans isomerization of glyoxalTheoretical Chemistry Accounts, 1975
- Structure-activity relations of phenethylamine. Comparison of quantum mechanical SCF ab initio and semiempirical calculationsJournal of the American Chemical Society, 1975
- Quantenchemische Berechnungen zur Molekülstruktur konjugierter Verbindungen. III.. Vergleichende π‐ und Allvalenzelektronen‐MO‐Berechnungen an Butadien‐(1,3), Glyoxal und BiphenylJournal für Praktische Chemie, 1974
- Etude conformationnelle dans l'approximation CNDO/BW: barrière de rotation interne de petites molécules organiquesHelvetica Chimica Acta, 1973
- A CNDO Study of BiphenylBulletin of the Chemical Society of Japan, 1973
- The interaction of directional lone pairs between bonded atoms: HydrazineTheoretical Chemistry Accounts, 1973
- Konformationsuntersuchungen mit Hilfe der Energieaufteilungsanalyse im CNDO‐, INDO‐ und NDDO‐Formalismus; Die Rotationsbarriere in der AmeisensäureZeitschrift für Chemie, 1972
- A reparametrization of the CNDO method I. HydrocarbonsTheoretical Chemistry Accounts, 1969