The Monty Hall Problem: Does Performance Improve After the Acquisition of Some Probability Knowledge?
Preprint
- 9 November 2025
- preprint
- Published by Qeios Ltd in Qeios Preprints
Abstract
The Monty Hall Problem (MHP) is a classic probability dilemma that is characterized by being counterintuitive even for experts in the field. The aim of this work was to study how a group of people assesses the chances of winning in the MHP and whether the decision they would make is consistent, with and without some knowledge of computing probability. The MHP was proposed to a group of students from a postgraduate program, before and after a class on probability. The students had to respond to two questions on each occasion: the first about the choice that they believed had more chances of winning and the second about what they would do. The results suggest that when participants had little knowledge of probability, they were more likely to rely on intuition, i.e., keep the selected door, whereas when they had more knowledge, they tended to consider both options as equally likely. Nevertheless, independently of which alternative they believed was more advantageous, most respondents would make the decision to stick to their first choice, probably evidencing biases such as the endowment effect, illusion of control, status quo, loss aversion, and anticipated regret.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- Three doors anomaly, “should I stay, or should I go”: an artefactual field experimentTheory and Decision, 2021
- Teaching the Monty Hall Dilemma to Explore Decision-Making, Probability, and Regret in Behavioral Science ClassroomsInternational Journal for the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning, 2018
- A randomised Monty Hall experiment: The positive effect of conditional frequency feedbackThinking & Reasoning, 2014
- The Monty Hall Problem2009
- Reasoning in the Monty Hall problem: Examining choice behaviour and probability judgementsThinking & Reasoning, 2003
- Further Exploration of Two-Stage Decision Making in the Monty Hall DilemmaThe American Journal of Psychology, 1998
- The Monty Hall Dilemma Donald GranbergPersonality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 1995
- Commission, Omission, and Dissonance Reduction: Coping with Regret in the "Monty Hall" ProblemPersonality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 1995
- Judgment under Uncertainty1982
- Mathematical GamesScientific American, 1959