The Insanity Defence: From wild Beasts to M'Naghten
Authors:
- 1 August 2007
- journal article
- review article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Australasian Psychiatry
- Vol. 15 (4) , 292-298
Abstract
Objective: This paper provides an overview of the insanity defence. An historical context is offered and each element of the M'Naghten Rules is discussed, highlighting differing interpretations within various jurisdictions. Discussion is offered on the role of expert evidence in addressing the ‘ultimate issue’ before the courts. Significant case law in relation to the insanity defence is highlighted. Conclusions: Psychiatrists have an important role to play in addressing issues central to the M'Naghten Rules and making these accessible and comprehensible to court and jurors in particular. Insanity is a legal construct designed to determine the extent to which a person may be deemed criminally responsible for a criminal act and is often difficult to reconcile within medical and public paradigms of mental illness and justice. Principles are offered to guide psychiatrists who are called to give evidence in cases where the mental illness defence has been raised.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- M'Naghten Revisited-Back to the Future? (The Mental Illness Defence-A Psychiatric Perspective)Current Issues in Criminal Justice, 2001
- Transfusion MedicineTransfusion, 1990
- 1. Psychiatric JusticeThe British Journal of Psychiatry, 1989
- From the EditorTheology Today, 1985
- The psychiatric expert in courtPsychological Medicine, 1984
- Review: Book reviewThe Computer Journal, 1980
- BOOK REVIEWSBritish Journal of Anaesthesia, 1979
- Army NotesRoyal United Services Institution. Journal, 1960
- R v CARTERVictorian Reports, 1959
- Deutscher ForstvereinForstwissenschaftliches Centralblatt, 1933