Comparison of homogenization methods for daily temperature series against an observation-based benchmark dataset
Open Access
- 7 January 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Theoretical and Applied Climatology
- Vol. 140 (1-2) , 285-301
Abstract
Homogenization of daily temperature series is a fundamental step for climatological analyses. In the last decades, several methods have been developed, presenting different statistical and procedural approaches. In this study, four homogenization methods (together with two variants) have been tested and compared. This has been performed constructing a benchmark dataset, where segments of homogeneous series are replaced with simultaneous measurements from neighboring homogeneous series. This generates inhomogeneous series (the test set) whose homogeneous version (the benchmark set) is known. Two benchmark datasets are created. The first one is based on series from the Czech Republic and has a high quality, high station density, and a large number of reference series. The second one uses stations from all Europe and presents more challenges, such as missing segments, low station density, and scarcity of reference series. The comparison has been performed with pre-defined metrics which check the statistical distance between the homogenized versions and the benchmark. Almost all homogenization methods perform well on the near-ideal benchmark (maximum relative root mean square error (rRMSE): 1.01), while on the European dataset, the homogenization methods diverge and the rRMSE increases up to 1.87. Analyses of the percentages of non-adjusted inhomogeneous data (up to 39%) and substantial differences in the trends among the homogenized versions helped identifying diverging procedural characteristics of the methods. These results add new elements to the debate about homogenization methods for daily values and motivate the use of realistic and challenging datasets in evaluating their robustness and flexibility.Keywords
Funding Information
- Copernicus Climate Change Service (C3S˙311a˙Lot4)
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- SPLIDHOM: A Method for Homogenization of Daily Temperature ObservationsJournal of Applied Meteorology and Climatology, 2011
- Efficiency evaluation for detecting inhomogeneities by objective homogenisation methodsTheoretical and Applied Climatology, 2011
- New Techniques for the Detection and Adjustment of Shifts in Daily Precipitation Data SeriesJournal of Applied Meteorology and Climatology, 2010
- Data quality control and homogenization of air temperature and precipitation series in the area of the Czech Republic in the period 1961–2007Advances in Science and Research, 2009
- Homogenization of Temperature Series via Pairwise ComparisonsJournal of Climate, 2009
- Penalized Maximal t Test for Detecting Undocumented Mean Change in Climate Data SeriesJournal of Applied Meteorology and Climatology, 2007
- A Method of Homogenizing the Extremes and Mean of Daily Temperature MeasurementsJournal of Climate, 2006
- Detection of Undocumented Changepoints Using Multiple Test Statistics and Composite Reference SeriesJournal of Climate, 2005
- Detection and Correction of Artificial Shifts in Climate SeriesJournal of the Royal Statistical Society Series C: Applied Statistics, 2004
- Daily dataset of 20th‐century surface air temperature and precipitation series for the European Climate AssessmentInternational Journal of Climatology, 2002