A meta-analysis of the mastitis vaccination efficacy in dairy cattle
Authors:
- Fernando MataFernando Mata
- Meirielly JesusMJMeirielly Jesus
- Ricardo PintoRicardo Pinto
- Andreia MataAMAndreia Mata
Open Access
- 1 January 2023
- journal article
- review article
- Published by ScopeMed in Open Veterinary Journal
- Vol. 13 (2) , 179-187
Abstract
Background: Mastitis is the most important disease in dairy cattle with impact in welfare of animals and the economy of the dairy farming activity. Attempts have been made to produce vaccines to prevent the disease, however results have been dubious. Aim: The aim of this study was to evaluate the efficacy of the mastitis vaccination in dairy cattle by merging several trials to allow evidence synthesis. Methods: A list of publications with common methodological grounds was selected to allow a quantitative comparison in a meta-analysis with moderators. Results: A mixed methods model (P< 0.001), with four significant moderators was successfully fitted: “year of publication” (P< 0.001), “vaccination timing” (P< 0.01), “type of animal” (P< 0.001) and “vaccine fabrication” (P< 0.001). The model is homogeneous (P> 0.05), with the moderators explaining the variability. Efficacy decreases over time. Vaccines applied after calving show inefficacy (log risk ratio 1.72 [1.34, 2.21]), and applied before calving show reduced efficacy (log risk ratio 0,86 [0.72, 1.03]). Commercial vaccines don’t show efficacy (log risk ratio 1,07 [0.94, 1.22]). Self-fabricated vaccines show efficacy (log risk ratio [0.51, 0.94]. Conclusion: Full clarification of efficacy is not shown; however, if vaccination is used, must follow a pre-calving protocol. While not showing efficacy, the vaccination has demonstrated a reduction of the severity in clinical cases, rate of culling, and has increased the production of milk and milk solids. Vaccination may improve health and welfare but does not prevent the disease effectively; It must be seen as an additional tool to the traditional preventive measures.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- An investigation of the efficacy of a polyvalent mastitis vaccine using different vaccination regimens under field conditions in the United KingdomJournal of Dairy Science, 2015
- Estimating the effect of mastitis on the profitability of Irish dairy farmsJournal of Dairy Science, 2012
- Efficacy of enterotoxigenicEscherichia colivaccine for bovine clinical mastitisJournal of Dairy Research, 2011
- Vaccines against bovine mastitis in the New Zealand context: What is the best way forward?New Zealand Veterinary Journal, 2009
- Comparison of J5 Vaccinates and Controls for Incidence, Etiologic Agent, Clinical Severity, and Survival in the Herd Following Naturally Occurring Cases of Clinical MastitisJournal of Dairy Science, 2007
- Staphylococcal vaccinesTrends in Immunology, 2002
- Field trial of a staphylococcal mastitis vaccine in dairy herds: clinical, subclinical and microbiological assessmentsAustralian Veterinary Journal, 1996
- Effect of Re-17 Mutant Salmonella typhimurium Bacterin Toxoid on Clinical Coliform MastitisJournal of Dairy Science, 1994
- A Field Trial with an Experimental Vaccine Against Staphylococcus aureus Mastitis in Cattle. 1. Clinical ParametersJournal of Dairy Science, 1994
- Vaccination Against MastitisJournal of Dairy Science, 1977