Abstract
This study develops a Shapley value-inspired analyst-specific measure to identify sellside analysts whose individual forecasts add more incremental value to the aggregate-level consensus forecast. I aggregate the marginal contributions of analysts to the consensus accuracy of firms in their coverage portfolio to obtain the value-added measure. Contrarian analysts with larger absolute forecast errors and larger deviations from consensus have greater incremental impact on consensus accuracy. In contrast, all-star analysts and analysts at larger brokerages add lower incremental value at the aggregate level. Timing of forecasts (either very timely or late) and job experience also positively affect forecast deviation and value-added. Overall, these findings demonstrate that contrarian analysts improve information aggregation despite their lower individual-level accuracy.