Kinesiology's Inconvenient Truth and the Physical Cultural Studies Imperative
- 14 February 2008
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Quest
- Vol. 60 (1) , 45-62
Abstract
This article explicates the inconvenient truth that is at the core of the crisis currently facing the field of kinesiology. Namely, the instantiation of an epistemological hierarchy that privileges positivist over postpositivist, quantitative over qualitative, and predictive over interpretive ways of knowing. The discussion outlines the political, economic, and cultural forces responsible for kinesiology's putative scientific hegemony and speaks to its corollary: the very demise of the field caused by intensified subdisciplinary specialization and fragmentation and fundamental lack of comprehensiveness. The article outlines a potential corrective to kinesiology's blinkered epistemological and empirical vision, currently being developed at the University of Maryland. Physical Cultural Studies (PCS) is introduced as a synthesis of empirical, theoretical, and methodological influences (drawn from, among other sources, the sociology and history of sport and physical activity, the sociology of the body, and cultural studies) that are focused on the critical analysis of active bodies and specifically the manner in which they become organized, represented, and experienced in relation to the operations of social power. Thus, PCS is offered as an important contribution toward realizing the truly integrative and comprehensive kinesiology to which we as kinesiologists—and regardless of our empirical, theoretical, or epistemological proclivities—should aspire.Keywords
This publication has 44 references indexed in Scilit:
- Managing the Toll of StrippingJournal of Contemporary Ethnography, 2007
- Bodies in Motion: The Sociology of Physical ActivityQuest, 2007
- Inscribing healthification: governance, risk, surveillance and the subjects and spaces of fitness and healthHealth & Place, 2006
- ‘Death to the Prancing Prince’: Effeminacy, Sport Discourses and the Salvation of Men's DancingBody & Society, 2005
- Globalisation and globesity: the impact of the 2008 Beijing Olympics on ChinaInternational Journal of Sport Management and Marketing, 2005
- Coming to Terms with Cultural StudiesJournal of Sport and Social Issues, 2002
- Cultural Studies as Performative PoliticsCultural Studies ↔ Critical Methodologies, 2001
- Decentering the Centre: Cultural Studies in Britain and its Legacy2001
- Conformity, diversity, and difference in antipodean physical culture: The indelible influence of immigration, ethnicity, and race during the formative years of organized sport in Australia, c. 1788–1918Immigrants & Minorities, 1998
- Bringing Bodies Back in: A Decade ReviewTheory, Culture & Society, 1990