The physical basis ofmb:Msand variable frequency magnitude methods for earthquake/explosion discrimination
Authors:
- Jeffry L. StevensJSJeffry L. Stevens
- Steven M. DaySDSteven M. Day
Open Access
- 10 March 1985
- journal article
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Geophysical Research
- Vol. 90 (B4) , 3009-3020
Abstract
We use recent results from deterministic numerical modeling of earthquakes and explosions to develop an improved physical basis for earthquake/explosion discrimination. We use six three‐dimensional finite difference simulations of earthquakes for the earthquake source models and four empirical and four numerical models for explosions in different materials. Four factors contribute to the success of themb:Msdiscriminant: source spectra, focal mechanism, near‐source elastic properties, and interference of ρp. Spectral differences contribute about 0.5 magnitude unit to the separation between earthquake and explosion populations for large events, but this difference vanishes for events withmb< 4.5. The difference in focal mechanism (quadrupole versus monopole) contributes about 0.35 magnitude unit on the average but also introduces a scatter of ±0.5 magnitude unit into the earthquake population. Differences in near‐source elastic properties tend to increase the separation, contributing a factor of approximately (ρα3)½(ρ is density and α isPwave speed) to the ratio of surface wave amplitude to body wave amplitude. Interference of ρpimproves discrimination for large, deeply buried explosions but may degrade or preventmb:Msdiscrimination of small, shallow explosions. If biases due to regional variations in propagation path are absent, or corrected for, we predict that themb:Msmethod will successfully discriminate most earthquakes from explosions, but there will be some overlap between populations at small magnitudes. The variable frequency magnitude (VFM) discriminant is based on spectral differences betweenPwaves produced by earthquakes and explosions. Theoretical separation of earthquake and explosion populations occurs for events withmb> 4.0, using a frequency band of 0.5–3.0 Hz. For small events the VFM discriminant is complementary tomb:Msin several ways: VFM is improved by ρpinterference, whilemb:Msis degraded; VFM is more effective for hard rock explosions, whilemb:Mswill preferentially discriminate explosions in low‐velocity materials; and VFM is insensitive to fault orientation. VFM is more sensitive to noise and regional attenuation differences thanmb:Ms. Simultaneous use of both methods should allow improved discrimination of small events.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- VFM Discrimination Results from a Ten Station Network1980
- Seismic Discrimination of Earthquakes and Explosions, with Application to the Southwestern United States1979
- Scaling Law of Earthquake Source Time-FunctionGeophysical Journal International, 1972
- A Quantitative Evaluation of Seismic Signals at Teleseismic Distances--III Computed P and Rayleigh Wave SeismogramsGeophysical Journal International, 1972
- Discrimination Between Earthquakes and Underground Explosions Employing an Improved Ms ScaleGeophysical Journal International, 1972
- The Relative Excitation of Seismic Surface and Body Waves by Point SourcesGeophysical Journal International, 1971
- Tectonic stress and the spectra of seismic shear waves from earthquakesJournal of Geophysical Research, 1970
- General theory of elastodynamic source fieldsReviews of Geophysics, 1968
- Scaling law of seismic spectrumJournal of Geophysical Research, 1967
- Total energy and energy spectral density of elastic wave radiation from propagating faults. Part II. A statistical source modelBulletin of the Seismological Society of America, 1966