Stimulating or constraining creativity? Traditional vs. generative AI on divergent thinking in product design
Authors:
Open Access
- 30 June 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Frontiers Media SA in Frontiers in Psychology
- Vol. 17, 1839565
Abstract
Introduction: The rise of generative AI (GenAI) has brought both opportunities and challenges to product design, raising the question of whether it stimulates or constrains creativity. This study empirically examines the effects of traditional and GenAI-assisted ideation methods on cognitive creativity and perceived creativity support during the divergent thinking stage of product design. Methods: Focusing on both the creativity of design outcomes and designers' self-reported user experience, a mixed-methods experiment was conducted with 41 sophomore students majoring in product design. Three ideation methods were compared: unaided, Internet-assisted, and GenAI-assisted. Results: The results revealed that, among novice product design students, traditional methods more effectively enhanced divergent thinking performance, whereas GenAI-assisted methods significantly improved designers' perceived creative support, specifically on usability, exploration, and immersion during the ideation process. Moreover, no significant differences were observed among participants with varying levels of creative tendency. Discussion: These findings suggest that, although GenAI has not yet surpassed traditional approaches in generating highly original design outcomes, it serves an important facilitative role in design education by enriching learners' creative perception and affective engagement. The study provides empirical evidence for the thoughtful integration of GenAI into the design process and highlights the need for future research on optimizing human-AI collaboration to augment, rather than replace, human creativity in design learning and practice.Keywords
This publication has 87 references indexed in Scilit:
- Divergent thinking and post-launch entrepreneurial outcomes: non-linearities and the moderating role of experienceSmall Business Economics, 2023
- Internet Use and Creative Thinking in the Alternative Uses TaskThe Journal of Creative Behavior, 2023
- Gender differences in creative design education: analysis of individual creativity and artefact perception in the first-year design studioInternational Journal of Technology and Design Education, 2022
- Role of cultural inspiration with different types in cultural product design activitiesInternational Journal of Technology and Design Education, 2016
- Choosing creativity: the role of individual risk and ambiguity aversion on creative concept selection in engineering designResearch in Engineering Design, 2016
- Mind mapping research methodsQuality & Quantity, 2011
- The use of creative stimuli at early stages of industrial product innovationResearch in Engineering Design, 2010
- Internet, World Wide Web, and CreativityThe Journal of Creative Behavior, 1999
- Usefulness of the Ideation Principle of Extended Effort in Real World Professional and Managerial Creative Problem Solving*The Journal of Creative Behavior, 1986
- Creativity: Yesterday, Today and TomorrowThe Journal of Creative Behavior, 1967