Comparison Between Two Hydrodynamic Models in Simulating Physical Processes of a Reservoir with Complex Morphology: Maroon Reservoir
Open Access
Abstract
Two 3D hydrodynamic models, AEM3D and MIKE3, are compared in simulating hydrodynamics of the Maroon Reservoir in southwest Iran. The reservoir has a complex bathymetry with steep walls, which makes it a good case for studying the performance of hydrodynamic models. The models were compared together and with measured water temperatures from different locations of the reservoir in a five-month period between December 2011 and April 2012. The results indicated that the AEM3D model, which uses a finite difference scheme with a purely z-level vertical discretization, showed better consistency with observations so that the AME and RMSE of the model remain below 1 °C. The MIKE3 model showed overall higher errors from 56% to 130% larger than AEM3D and the level of error strongly depends on its vertical discretization method and the turbulence model. The lowest errors by MIKE3 were seen by the k-ε turbulence model with a hybrid z-sigma discretization, while the highest errors were generated by using the sigma vertical discretization. The vertical mixing model in AEM3D model, used instead of the constant eddy viscosity or k-ε formulation, showed a better performance in modeling vertical mixing and wind mixed layer, which is another reason of observing better results by this model than MIKE3. Overall, this study shows AEM3D as a more appropriate model for simulating deep and complex reservoirs with steep slopes and walls.Keywords
This publication has 39 references indexed in Scilit:
- Pre-impoundment assessment of the limnological processes and eutrophication in a reservoir using three-dimensional modeling: Abolabbas reservoir, IranJournal of Applied Water Engineering and Research, 2016
- The structure of basin‐scale internal waves in a stratified lake in response to lake bathymetry and wind spatial and temporal distribution: Lake Iseo, ItalyLimnology and Oceanography, 2012
- Dynamics of the benthic boundary layer in a strongly forced stratified lakeHydrobiologia, 2006
- Modeling circulation in lakes: Spatial and temporal variationsLimnology and Oceanography, 2003
- High‐frequency internal waves in large stratified lakesLimnology and Oceanography, 2003
- Modeling basin‐scale internal waves in a stratified lakeLimnology and Oceanography, 2000
- Prediction of water quality in lakes and reservoirs. Part I — Model descriptionEcological Modelling, 1997
- Prediction of water quality in lakes and reservoirs: Part II - Model calibration, sensitivity analysis and applicationEcological Modelling, 1997
- Semi‐implicit finite difference methods for three‐dimensional shallow water flowInternational Journal for Numerical Methods in Fluids, 1992
- A COORDINATE SYSTEM HAVING SOME SPECIAL ADVANTAGES FOR NUMERICAL FORECASTINGJournal of Meteorology, 1957