There is a widely held belief that narrative meaning-making is an important activity for people suffering from debilitating conditions. Less attention is given to those who are close to them, who may be carrying heavy burdens of their own over an extended period. This is typically a situation of existential stress, and it could be seen as a threat to the existential health of the involved persons. This chapter addresses the process of existential meaning-making as expressed in narratives in an online group discussion by present and former carers of people living with dementia. The act of storytelling is for many caregivers an effort at making sense, combatting chaos, and tolerating ambiguity. Furthermore, sharing narratives can be a collective attempt to find answers to the question of meaning.