Comparison of Credible Patients of Very Low Intelligence and Non-Credible Patients on Neurocognitive Performance Validity Indicators
Authors:
- 2 July 2014
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Clinical Neuropsychologist
- Vol. 28 (6) , 1048-1070
Abstract
The purpose of this archival study was to identify performance validity tests (PVTs) and standard IQ and neurocognitive test scores, which singly or in combination, differentiate credible patients of low IQ (FSIQ ≤ 75; n = 55) from non-credible patients. We compared the credible participants against a sample of 74 non-credible patients who appeared to have been attempting to feign low intelligence specifically (FSIQ ≤ 75), as well as a larger non-credible sample (n = 383) unselected for IQ. The entire non-credible group scored significantly higher than the credible participants on measures of verbal crystallized intelligence/semantic memory and manipulation of overlearned information, while the credible group performed significantly better on many processing speed and memory tests. Additionally, credible women showed faster finger-tapping speeds than non-credible women. The credible group also scored significantly higher than the non-credible subgroup with low IQ scores on measures of attention, visual perceptual/spatial tasks, processing speed, verbal learning/list learning, and visual memory, and credible women continued to outperform non-credible women on finger tapping. When cut-offs were selected to maintain approximately 90% specificity in the credible group, sensitivity rates were highest for verbal and visual memory measures (i.e., TOMM trials 1 and 2; Warrington Words correct and time; Rey Word Recognition Test total; RAVLT Effort Equation, Trial 5, total across learning trials, short delay, recognition, and RAVLT/RO discriminant function; and Digit Symbol recognition), followed by select attentional PVT scores (i.e., b Test omissions and time to recite four digits forward). When failure rates were tabulated across seven most sensitive scores, a cut-off of ≥ 2 failures was associated with 85.4% specificity and 85.7% sensitivity, while a cut-off of ≥ 3 failures resulted in 95.1% specificity and 66.0% sensitivity. Results are discussed in light of extant literature and directions for future research.Keywords
This publication has 38 references indexed in Scilit:
- Cross validation of the Lu and colleagues (2003) Rey-Osterrieth Complex Figure Test effort equation in a large known-group sampleArchives of Clinical Neuropsychology, 2012
- Development and Validation of the Stanford Binet-5 Rarely Missed Items-Nonverbal Index for the Detection of Malingered Mental RetardationArchives of Clinical Neuropsychology, 2011
- Effects of education and cultural background on performance on WAIS-III, WMS-III, WAIS-R and WMS-R measures: Systematic reviewAustralian Psychologist, 2009
- Detecting Malingering in Traumatic Brain Injury and Chronic Pain: A Comparison of Three Forced-Choice Symptom Validity TestsThe Clinical Neuropsychologist, 2008
- Identification of Feigned Mental Retardation Using the New Generation of Malingering Detection Instruments: Preliminary FindingsThe Clinical Neuropsychologist, 2007
- Malingering on the Social Security Disability Consultative Exam: A New Rating ScaleArchives of Clinical Neuropsychology, 2007
- A farewell to Bonferroni: the problems of low statistical power and publication biasBehavioral Ecology, 2004
- Diagnostic Criteria for Malingered Neurocognitive Dysfunction: Proposed Standards for Clinical Practice and ResearchThe Clinical Neuropsychologist, 1999
- Malingering Detection in a Mentally Retarded Forensic PopulationApplied Neuropsychology, 1998
- Malingering and other validity considerations in the neuropsychological evaluation of mild head injuryJournal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology, 1993