Expert-Based Risk Mapping for Low-Carbon Hydrogen Production Under Geopolitical Constraints: A Case Study of Russia
Open Access
Abstract
The transition to low-carbon hydrogen is recognized as a priority decarbonization pathway, yet the risk profiles of hydrogen projects remain poorly characterized for non-Western, resource-rich, and geopolitically constrained economies. This study develops and applies a structured expert-based risk mapping framework for low-carbon hydrogen production in Russia. The framework integrates three procedural steps: (1) identification and classification of 21 risk factors across seven thematic groups based on systematic literature analysis; (2) construction of a directed interdependency matrix (7 × 7, ordinal scale 0–2) via structured expert elicitation (n = 10, February 2026); and (3) probability–impact prioritization using the P × S scoring heuristic (both axes on a 1–5 scale, per ISO 31000:2018). Results reveal three critical risk factors (P × S Score ≥ 20): high cost of capital and restricted access to external financing (Score = 24, P = 5, S = 5), dependence on imported electrolyzer components (Score = 20, P = 4, S = 4), and insufficient export infrastructure (Score = 20, P = 5, S = 4). The interdependency matrix identifies economic and financial risks as the primary “accumulator” of systemic influence, receiving maximum incoming impact from all other six groups. Regulatory risks occupy a medium position but exert disproportionate cascading effects on technology choice and project economics. The framework is explicitly designed for transferability to other resource-abundant, capital-constrained economies (Kazakhstan, Iran, Algeria), with structural adaptation conditions specified. Findings are relevant for policymakers, investors, and multilateral stakeholders shaping hydrogen value chains in non-Western contexts.Keywords
Funding Information
- Russian Science Foundation (22-78-10089-П)
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- A framework for political risk management and its application to the German-West African green hydrogen activitiesEnergy Conversion and Management: X, 2026
- 50 shades of hydrogen: A perspective on definitions in science and public communicationEnergy Research & Social Science, 2025
- Exploring hydrogen energy systems: A comprehensive review of technologies, applications, prevailing trends, and associated challengesJournal of Energy Storage, 2024
- Advancements in hydrogen energy systems: A review of levelized costs, financial incentives and technological innovationsInnovation and Green Development, 2024
- Perspective under uncertainty and risk in green hydrogen investments: A stochastic approach using Monte Carlo simulationInternational Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2023
- A comprehensive review of the promising clean energy carrier: Hydrogen production, transportation, storage, and utilization (HPTSU) technologiesFuel, 2023
- The sustainability of green hydrogen: An uncertain propositionInternational Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2023
- Hydrogen production methods: Benefits, opportunities, costs, and risks2023
- Emerging technologies by hydrogen: A reviewInternational Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2020
- High-temperature electrolysis for large-scale hydrogen and syngas production from nuclear energy – summary of system simulation and economic analysesInternational Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 2010