Visual and instrumental coverage error of two dental shade guides: an in vivo study
Open Access
- 31 May 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Clinical Oral Investigations
- Vol. 26 (9) , 5961-5968
Abstract
Objectives: This study aims to evaluate in vivo the color agreement between natural teeth and dental shade guides by means of visual and instrumental coverage error ( $$\mathrm{CE}$$ ) index.Materials and methods: The color of the middle third of 735 incisors was visually determined by two evaluators using the Vita Classical (VC) and Vita 3D Master (V3DM) shade guides. The color match between the natural tooth and the shade tab was rated as poor (P), good (G), or optimum (O) by each observer. CIE color coordinates of the target teeth and shade tabs of VC and V3DM were instrumentally measured using a clinical spectrophotometer. Visual ( $${\mathrm{CE}}_{\mathrm{V}}$$ ) and instrumental ( $${\mathrm{CE}}_{\mathrm{I}}$$ ) coverage error indexes were computed using CIELAB and CIEDE2000 metrics for both shade guides. For $${\mathrm{CE}}_{\mathrm{V}}$$ calculation, only the concordant inter-observer determination on tooth shade rated as O–O or O–G was used. The results were evaluated using perceptibility (PT, $${\mathrm{\Delta E}}_{\mathrm{ab}}^{*}$$ = 1.2, $${\mathrm{\Delta E}}_{00}$$ = 0.8) and acceptability (AT, $${\mathrm{\Delta E}}_{\mathrm{ab}}^{*}$$ = 2.7, $${\mathrm{\Delta E}}_{00}$$ = 1.8) color thresholds for dentistry.Results: VC and V3DM exhibited $${\mathrm{CE}}_{\mathrm{I}}$$ (2.5, 3.2, and 3.2, 2.7 CIELAB units; 1.9, 2.3, and 2.8, 2.4 CIEDE2000 units, respectively, for O–O and O–G match) and $${\mathrm{CE}}_{\mathrm{V}}$$ (4.7, 4.8, and 4.1, 4.6 CIELAB units; 3.3, 3.4, and 3.4, 3.6 CIEDE2000 units, respectively, for O–O and O–G match) values greater than 50:50% AT for both color difference formulas. $${\mathrm{CE}}_{\mathrm{I}}$$ contributes more than 50% (53.2–82.4% range) to the $${\mathrm{CE}}_{\mathrm{V}}$$ value. This contribution depends on the shade guide used and the quality of the visual rating.Conclusions: The evaluated shade guides exhibited visual coverage errors above acceptability thresholds, largely due to the contribution of the instrumental coverage error to the visual coverage error.Clinical relevance: It necessary to further improve commercially available dental shade guides to facilitate achievement of satisfactory esthetics results in clinical practice.
Keywords
Funding Information
- Junta de Andalucía (P20-00200, A.TEP.280.UGR18)
- Ministerio de Ciencia, Innovación y Universidades (PGC2018-101904-A-I00)
- Universidad de Granada
This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- An Evaluation of Shade Differences Between Natural Anterior Teeth in Different Age Groups and Gender Using Commercially Available Shade GuidesThe Journal of Indian Prosthodontic Society, 2012
- Reliability of shade selection using an intraoral spectrophotometerClinical Oral Investigations, 2011
- Four color-measuring devices compared with a spectrophotometric reference systemJournal of Dentistry, 2010
- Dental color matching instruments and systems. Review of clinical and research aspectsJournal of Dentistry, 2010
- Reliability and accuracy of four dental shade-matching devicesThe Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry, 2009
- Performance assessment of dental shade guidesJournal of Dentistry, 2009
- Variations of L*a*b* Values among Vitapan® Classical Shade GuidesJournal of Prosthodontics, 2007
- Defining a natural tooth color space based on a 3-dimensional shade systemThe Journal of Prosthetic Dentistry, 2007
- Optimization of Tooth Color and Shade Guide DesignJournal of Prosthodontics, 2007
- Performance of Five Commercially Available Tooth Color‐Measuring DevicesJournal of Prosthodontics, 2007