Participants in the present study, 646 Brazilians, completed an online survey in which they indicated how they perceived plant-based meat substitutes and cultured meat, how much they knew about these products, and how willing they were to eat these products. They also described their diet, and they completed a measure of vegetarian threat. Regression analyses found that the willingness to eat both types of meat substitutes was related to how healthy, safe, and beneficial to the environment the products were perceived to be. Although plant-based meats were perceived to be healthier and safer than cultured meat for all participants, these differences were larger for vegetarians than they were for omnivores. Vegetarians were less likely to eat cultured meat than plant based meat, whereas the reverse was true for omnivores. Omnivores’ evaluations of both plant-based and cultured meat were negatively related to their perceptions of vegetarianism as a threat to their social values. Finally, the perceived benefits of plant-based and cultured meats, although positively related, represented separate latent factors. The results suggest that although plant-based and cultured meat are both meat substitutes, consumers may see them as meaningfully different products, and such differences may vary across different groups of consumers.