Variations in the elemental C:N:P ratios of organic matter (OM) influence carbon cycling and the coupling of carbon and nutrient cycles in the global coastal and open oceans. In this study, we assess the relevance of OM stoichiometry for regional carbon cycling in the northwest European shelf seas (NWES), with a focus on the efficiency of the continental shelf carbon pump mechanism. We incorporate two pathways for variable OM stoichiometry into the coupled regional physical-biogeochemical modeling system SCHISM-ECOSMO-CO2: the extracellular release of carbon-enriched dissolved organic matter under nutrient limitation and the preferential remineralization of organic nitrogen and phosphorus over carbon. Observational and experimental evidence demonstrate that these mechanisms enhance nutrient recycling, new production, and carbon fixation beyond nutrient co-limitation. We assess the changes in both the organic and inorganic carbon budgets of the NWES and link the previously demonstrated increase in CO2 uptake of approximately 10–30% through intensified OM cycling to a proportionate increase in the subsequent export of dissolved inorganic carbon. Depending on the relative contribution of the two mechanisms, roughly 60–90% of the additional CO2 uptake is exported across the shelf break, primarily via the Norwegian Trench. In contrast, the organic carbon budget shows smaller and more variable contributions in time. These results demonstrate that OM stoichiometry regulates the efficiency of the continental shelf carbon pump mechanism in the NWES. Our study emphasizes the importance of OM stoichiometry for carbon fluxes and export in the coastal and open oceans, highlighting its impact on regional and global carbon cycling.