The situated critic or the loyal critic? Rorty and Walzer on social criticism
Author:
- 1 November 1998
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Philosophy & Social Criticism
- Vol. 24 (6) , 25-46
Abstract
This article addresses the question whether the model of social criticism as 'connected' or 'loyal' which is advanced by Richard Rorty and Michael Walzer offers an adequate picture of social criticism. Two claims are made. First, it is suggested that loyalty is an internally conflicted concept, with three components: a recognition of situatedness in a particu lar relationship; an affirmation of that relationship by the loyal agent; a set of values or local principles. Where the third component is prominent, loyalty is more reflective and distanced; where the second component predominates, loyalty slips into unreflective commitment. Second, it is argued that Rorty and Walzer conflate the social critic's recognition of his or her situatedness in contexts of power with the affirmation of that situ atedness. It is concluded that the model of loyal social criticism is mislead mg, and that the practice of the critic must be tempered by the operation of the sense of injustice.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- “Survival in Justice”: An Afrikaner Debate over ApartheidComparative Studies in Society and History, 1994
- Obligation, Loyalty, ExilePolitical Theory, 1993
- Political Criticism1990
- Review EssaysReligious Studies Review, 1990
- Two Cheers for the Cultural LeftSouth Atlantic Quarterly, 1990
- Contingency, Irony, and Solidarity1989
- II. Thugs and TheoristsPolitical Theory, 1987
- Michael Walzer's 'Exodus and Revolution': A Canaanite ReadingGrand Street, 1986
- The Magic in the Pronoun "My"Moral Luck. Bernard WilliamsEthics, 1983
- LoyaltiesThe Journal of Philosophy, 1982