Using the Victim Role as Both Sword and Shield
Authors:
- 23 August 2008
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Contemporary Ethnography
- Vol. 38 (3) , 279-307
Abstract
Recently, criminal justice professionals have advocated restorative justice as an alternative to traditional punitive practices. Extant research has not examined the strategic interpersonal dynamics between victims, offenders, supporters, and facilitators during restorative justice sessions. Our ethnographic study addresses this gap. Building on studies of emotion in reintegrative shaming, we explore how shaming emotions are dramaturgically mediated by the rhetorical use of victim roles. We suggest that this micropolitical shame management facilitates apparently meaningful outcomes, undermines them, or results in agreements based more on realpolitik than reintegration. Our data are derived from detailed field notes at 28 youth restorative justice sessions in a mid-sized Canadian city. Our findings reveal a different picture than the frequently idealized images of restorative justice, thus underscoring the need for further analysis in this important area of criminal justice.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Reintegrative Shaming, Shame, and Criminal JusticeJournal of Social Issues, 2006
- Justice From the Victim’s PerspectiveViolence Against Women, 2005
- The Politics of Risk and Young Offenders’ Experiences of Social Exclusion and Restorative JusticeThe British Journal of Criminology, 2005
- Restorative Justice and the Absent Victim: New Data from the Thames ValleyInternational Review of Victimology, 2002
- Inequality and the Self: Exploring Connections from an Interactionist PerspectiveSymbolic Interaction, 2001
- Confrontations and Compromise: Dispute Resolution at a Worker Cooperative Coal MineLaw & Social Inquiry, 2001
- Restorative Justice: Assessing Optimistic and Pessimistic AccountsCrime and Justice, 1999
- Public Conflict Resolution: A Transformative ApproachNegotiation Journal, 1993
- RETHINKING VICTIMIZATION: AN INTERACTIONAL APPROACH TO VICTIMOLOGYSymbolic Interaction, 1990
- On Last ResortsAmerican Journal of Sociology, 1981