Abstract
The interplay between science and politics is increasingly complex and contentious, especially in times of crises and polarized public debates. Although calls to "follow the science" are often invoked in political discourse, science’s role in politics is rarely straightforward, and it is frequently used strategically beyond its informational function. This study examines how science-related political communication influences perceived message credibility and communicator trustworthiness, integrating insights from science communication and political communication research. We empirically test hypotheses across three conceptual dimensions. First, we evaluate the effects of source credibility by comparing communicators (scientists vs. politicians) and their respective uses of evidence. Second, we analyze the impact of different rhetorical strategies employed to communicate the political decision-making process, like highlighting evidence-determined justifications, reasoned processes, or populist appeals. Third, we investigate how science-populist attitudes and pre-existing issue-attitudes moderate these effects. Results of a pre-registered factorial survey experiment (N = 552) show that source credibility and the choice of evidence are primary drivers of perceived credibility and trustworthiness. In contrast, rhetorical strategies related to decision-making processes have no significant effect. Notably, science-populist attitudes strongly influence which epistemic authorities respondents consider legitimate bases for political decisions. These findings reveal tensions at the science-politics nexus between the strategic effectiveness of constructing epistemic authority and the normative democratic demand for political accountability. The study contributes novel empirical insights into how communicative strategies shape trust in science-related political communication, offering implications for safeguarding trust in science and improving the credibility and trustworthiness of political communication in polarized environments.