Generative Artificial Intelligence in Scientific Research: Individual Benefits, Collective Risks, and a Framework for Responsible Research with Artificial Intelligence

Authors:

Abstract
This commentary examines the tension between the benefits of generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) for scientific research and the unresolved governance questions that accompany its rapid adoption. Drawing on an academic roundtable held at the AI for Science and Innovation Workshop (Scuola IMT Alti Studi Lucca, April 2026) and on the rapidly growing empirical literature, it maps a disagreement within the research community across four stages of the research process, namely funding, research tasks, publication and peer review, and use and uptake. The empirical case for AI's productivity, augmentation, and democratization effects is growing, but the picture sharpens once productivity is disaggregated. AI-assisted papers show clear gains in publication volume and citation share, while novelty, disruption, and breakthrough output exhibit more ambiguous trends. The commentary proposes that the policy conversation move beyond the binary of "AI is beneficial" versus "AI is dangerous" toward frameworks organized around four operational principles, namely disclosure, narrative, differentiation, and proportionality. The proposed Responsible Research with AI (RRAI) builds on existing institutional scaffolding (EU AI Act, UNESCO, OECD), aiming to capture AI's productivity gains while addressing the systemic risks that individual researchers cannot manage on their own.