Meaning-Making as Dialogic Process: Official and Carnival Lives in the Language Classroom
- 31 August 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Language, Identity & Education
- Vol. 8 (4) , 236-253
Abstract
This article adopts a Bakhtinian analysis to understand the complexities of discourse in language-learning classrooms. Drawing on empirical data from two of four linked case studies in a larger, ESRC-funded project, we argue that students learning in complementary (also known as community language, supplementary, or heritage language) schools create “second lives” in the classroom. They do this through the use of carnivalesque language, introducing new voices into classroom discourse, using mockery and parody to subvert tradition and authority, and engaging in the language of “grotesque realism.” Students use varieties of parodic language to mock their teacher, to mock each other, to mock notional students as second-language learners, and to mock their school's attempts to transmit reified versions of “cultural heritage.” These creative discourse strategies enable the students to create carnival lives in the classroom that provide alternatives to the official worlds of their teachers. In doing so the students are able to move in and out of official and carnival worlds, making meaning in discourse that is dialogic, as they represent themselves and others in voices that cut across boundaries in complex, creative, sophisticated ways.Keywords
This publication has 12 references indexed in Scilit:
- 'The Rotation Gets Thick. The Constraints Get Thin': Creativity, Recontextualization, and DifferenceApplied Linguistics, 2007
- Everyday Creativity in Language: Textuality, Contextuality, and CritiqueApplied Linguistics, 2007
- Carnival in a Mainstream Kindergarten Classroom: A Bakhtinian Analysis of Second Language Learners' Off‐Task BehaviorsThe Modern Language Journal, 2007
- Bilingualism: A Social Approach2007
- Heteroglossia and Boundaries2007
- Language in Late Modernity2006
- Multicultural, Heritage and Learner Identities in Complementary SchoolsLanguage and Education, 2006
- Children's Voices2006
- Discourse and Power in a Multilingual World2005
- Identity and the Young English Language Learner2002