Systematic review of outcomes reported in clinical research on nephronophthisis: how do they align with SONG Kids priorities?
Open Access
- 20 August 2025
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Springer Nature in Pediatric Nephrology
- Vol. 41 (2) , 339-351
Abstract
Background: Nephronophthisis (NPH) is a rare hereditary cystic kidney disease, characterized by a highly variable clinical and genetic presentation, accounting for up to 10% of kidney failure in children. Despite advances in understanding its molecular basis and phenotypic spectrum, no causative therapies exist, and clinical trials remain absent. To support future treatment development, patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) tailored to NPH should be defined to prioritize outcomes meaningful to patients and families. Objectives: This study aimed to analyze the use of clinical data, surrogate parameters, and patient-reported outcomes in NPH research to date, with a focus on the Standardized Outcomes in Nephrology (SONG) project outcomes validated for children with chronic kidney disease (SONG Kids). Data sources: A systematic search of the MEDLINE database was conducted for NPH studies. Study eligibility criteria: Studies published after 1988, written in English, reporting at least one human clinical outcome, with a sample size of n ≥ 4, and using original data were considered eligible. Results: A total of 1066 records were retrieved through the search, of which 821 full-text reports were assessed for eligibility. Of these, 90 studies met eligibility criteria and were included in the review. While 100% of the studies reported clinical outcomes and 85% included surrogate parameter, only 41% examined patient-reported outcomes. Overlap between the SONG Kids outcome set and the outcomes identified in this study was moderate. Only 20 studies reported more than one SONG core outcome, while 24% and 66% of studies reported at least one middle tier or outer tier outcome, respectively. None of these studies used instruments validated for NPH. Limitations: The majority of studies focused primarily on molecular and genetic aspects, with clinical outcomes addressed only as a secondary consideration. The review incorporated only one prospective study, while the remaining studies were retrospective in nature. Differentiation between outcomes reported by children and those reported by parents was not possible in the included studies; this important distinction must be taken into account in the development of future PROMs for NPH. Conclusions and implications of key findings: Studies in NPH addressed both clinical outcomes and surrogate parameters, but there is a notable absence of measures related to life participation and patient-reported outcomes. Disease group-specific instruments fall short in adequately reflecting the symptoms of individual diseases, emphasizing the necessity for the development of disease-specific PROMs for NPH. Open Science Framework (OSF) registration: https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/658BR GraphicalKeywords
This publication has 54 references indexed in Scilit:
- Development of a patient-reported outcome measure for the assessment of symptom burden in pediatric chronic kidney disease (PRO-Kid)Pediatric Nephrology, 2021
- Systematic review on outcomes used in clinical research on autosomal recessive polycystic kidney disease—are patient-centered outcomes our blind spot?Pediatric Nephrology, 2021
- Epidemiology of pediatric chronic kidney disease/kidney failure: learning from registries and cohort studiesPediatric Nephrology, 2021
- The Use of Patient-Reported Outcome Measures in Rare Diseases and Implications for Health Technology AssessmentThe Patient - Patient-Centered Outcomes Research, 2021
- Clinical and genetic analyses of a Dutch cohort of 40 patients with a nephronophthisis-related ciliopathyPediatric Nephrology, 2018
- Identification of 99 novel mutations in a worldwide cohort of 1,056 patients with a nephronophthisis-related ciliopathyHuman Genetics, 2013
- The diagnostic value of ultrasound in cystic kidney diseasesPediatric Nephrology, 2010
- NephronophthisisPediatric Nephrology, 2008
- Sonographic findings in familial juvenile nephronophthisis–medullary cystic disease complexJournal of Clinical Ultrasound, 1998
- Development of the Kidney Disease Quality of Life (KDQOLTM) InstrumentQuality of Life Research, 1994