Comparative evaluation of malvasia wines: concordance and reliability of judgments
- 28 February 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Wine Research
- Vol. 28 (2) , 144-158
Abstract
Judgments given by experts in wine-tasting competitions can be relevant in terms of the visible signs of quality they provide for consumers. Even though it is difficult to measure the quality of wines in absolute terms, sensorial analysis through tasting is the generally accepted way to assess it. In this paper, a statistical analysis is carried out of the results from the first competition of Malvasias of the World. The evaluations obtained according to wine type (dry or sweet), geographical location and judge are analyzed and compared. Additionally, possible differences between two Canarian varieties of malvasia (aromatic and volcanic malvasia) are analyzed. Finally, the internal consistency of two tastings using a range of statistical measures based on the judges’ scores is studied to show the degree of concordance and reliability among their wine judgments.Keywords
Funding Information
- University of La Laguna (1075/2015)
This publication has 35 references indexed in Scilit:
- Evaluating Wine-Tasting Results and Randomness with a Mixture of Rank Preference ModelsJournal of Wine Economics, 2015
- Quantifying Randomness Versus Consensus in Wine Quality RatingsJournal of Wine Economics, 2014
- The impact of expert opinion in consumer perception of winesInternational Journal of Wine Business Research, 2013
- Is There Consensus Among Wine Quality Ratings of Prominent Critics? An Empirical Analysis of Red Bordeaux, 2004–2010Journal of Wine Economics, 2013
- 804 Tastes: Evidence on Preferences, Randomness, and Value from Double-Blind Wine TastingsJournal of Wine Economics, 2012
- Reliability and Consensus of Experienced Wine Judges: Expertise Within and Between?Journal of Wine Economics, 2012
- A Bayesian Approach to Ranking and Rater EvaluationJournal of Educational and Behavioral Statistics, 2010
- Evaluation of Wine Judge Performance through Three Characteristics: Bias, Discrimination, and VariationJournal of Wine Economics, 2010
- Tales from the Crypt: Auctioneer Bruce Kaiser Tells Us about the Trials and Tribulations of a Wine JudgeJournal of Wine Economics, 2006
- Modelling and monitoring the decision process of wine tasting panellistsFood Quality and Preference, 2005