The precautionary principle, uncertainty and the Noah’s Ark problem
Author:
- 3 May 2013
- journal article
- review article
- Published by CSIRO Publishing in Wildlife Research
- Vol. 40 (2) , 117-125
Abstract
Multiple biodiversity objectives have been proposed in conservation planning and economics for the Noah’s Ark problem – the problem of allocating limited funds to conservation projects – including species richness, persistence, taxonomic diversity, representativeness, the charismatic value of species, the broader concept of direct utility and ecological importance. However, these objectives are incommensurable and there is little consensus about which objective should be pursued, given the current state of nature. In economics, this is perhaps because the commensurability problem can be solved by converting all biodiversity objectives to monetary values. Yet, even here, a commensurability problem exists because fundamental uncertainty about species interactions means that ecological values cannot be represented in economic terms. Thus, maximising biodiversity value, combined as it is with a rational decision-making framework and assumed known probabilities of survival, can undermine the very values being pursued. This is especially the case when climate change is a current and future state of nature. Climate change adds additional complexity and fundamental uncertainties to the survival probabilities, the future value of species, the interactions among species and the probability of success of conservation projects. The associated incomplete information can lead decision makers to risky decisions under the current approach. Instead, under such conditions, the precautionary principle is appropriate. This leads to a broad conservation strategy of minimising the maximum regret and, when applied to the Noah’s Ark problem, an objective of ecosystem resilience or functional diversity rather than an objective based on economic values. The paper therefore provides an economic justification for focussing conservation resources and threatened species legislation on the resilience of ecosystems.Keywords
This publication has 38 references indexed in Scilit:
- Separate or mixed production of timber, livestock and biodiversity in the Caspian ForestEcological Economics, 2010
- The ecological importance of species and the Noah's Ark problemEcological Economics, 2010
- A Review of Climate‐Change Adaptation Strategies for Wildlife Management and Biodiversity ConservationConservation Biology, 2009
- On the Productive Value of BiodiversityEnvironmental and Resource Economics, 2008
- THE INSURANCE VALUE OF BIODIVERSITY IN THE PROVISION OF ECOSYSTEM SERVICESNatural Resource Modeling, 2007
- Biodiversity pressure and the driving forces behindEcological Economics, 2007
- EFFECTS OF BIODIVERSITY ON ECOSYSTEM FUNCTIONING: A CONSENSUS OF CURRENT KNOWLEDGEEcological Monographs, 2005
- Optimal climate policy is a utopia: from quantitative to qualitative cost-benefit analysisEcological Economics, 2004
- Economic valuation of biodiversity: sense or nonsense?Ecological Economics, 2001
- Conservation evaluation and phylogenetic diversityBiological Conservation, 1992