Long‐term reevaluation of spatially explicit models as a means for adaptive wildlife management
Open Access
- 3 February 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Ecological Applications
- Vol. 30 (4) , e02088
Abstract
We evaluated a 20‐yr‐old spatially explicit model (SEM) that predicted the spatial expansion of reintroduced Persian fallow deer in northern Israel. Using the current distribution of the deer and based on multi‐model inference we assessed the accuracy of theSEM's prediction and what other factors affected the population's current distribution. If theSEM's projection was still valid, the leading model in the multi‐model inference would include only theSEM's projection as an explanatory variable with a good fit. Different leading models would reveal key variables overlooked when theSEMwas constructed or changes in the landscape unforeseen at the time, thus assisting adaptive management and decision‐making. We assessed deer presence from camera trap encounter counts analyzed using N‐mixture models. Models included various combinations of seven predictors: the 20‐yr predictions of anSEMdeveloped during the initial phases of the reintroduction, three key landscape characteristics on which theSEMwas originally based but updated to reflect current conditions, distance from the release site, elevation, and the distribution of gray wolves (a predator that was absent from the area when theSEMwas developed). Competing models were ranked by Akaike information criterion (AIC). Wolf distribution was the key predictor explaining the current deer distribution, appearing in all three leading models (∆AIC < 2.0) and carrying 71% of theAICweight (coefficient = −14.86 ± 5.6 [mean ± SE]). Of these three models, theSEM20‐yr prediction appeared in two, but explained only a fraction of the variance (coefficient = 0.001 ± 0.08). The contribution of all other predictors was negligible. While theSEMfailed to accurately predict the 20‐yr deer distribution, the divergence between its projection and reality pointed to the probable cause (wolves) of this discrepancy. The inclusion of theSEMprediction in the leading models indicates that had the wolves not spread to the study area, the predictions would still have merit suggesting that long‐termSEMs can potentially be robust. Long‐term reevaluation ofSEMs can be beneficial even if model projections fail, as the process can uncover the specific factors driving this failure, supporting adaptive management procedures.Keywords
This publication has 37 references indexed in Scilit:
- Likelihood analysis of species occurrence probability from presence‐only data for modelling species distributionsMethods in Ecology and Evolution, 2012
- Predation determines the outcome of 10 reintroduction attempts in arid South AustraliaBiological Conservation, 2011
- PREDICTING THE SPATIAL DYNAMICS OF A REINTRODUCED POPULATION: THE PERSIAN FALLOW DEEREcological Applications, 2005
- THE GOLAN WOLVES: THE DYNAMICS, BEHAVIORAL ECOLOGY, AND MANAGEMENT OF AN ENDANGERED PESTIsrael Journal of Zoology, 2005
- Presence‐absence versus presence‐only modelling methods for predicting bird habitat suitabilityEcography, 2004
- Seasonal and Circadian Changes in the Home Ranges of Reintroduced Persian Fallow DeerThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 2003
- Impacts of Landscape Change on Wolf Restoration Success: Planning a Reintroduction Program Based on Static and Dynamic Spatial ModelsConservation Biology, 2003
- Impact of Repeated Releases on Space-Use Patterns of Persian Fallow DeerThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 2002
- Assessing the suitability of central European landscapes for the reintroduction of Eurasian lynxJournal of Applied Ecology, 2002
- A long‐term systematic approach to planning reintroductions: the Persian fallow deer and the Arabian oryx in IsraelAnimal Conservation, 1998