A Comparison of Energy Expenditure Estimation of Several Physical Activity Monitors
- 1 November 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise
- Vol. 45 (11) , 2105-2112
Abstract
In improved estimates of EE. Purpose This study aimed to determine the validity of EE estimation of a footwear-based physical activity monitor and to compare this validity against a variety of research and consumer physical activity monitors. Methods Nineteen healthy young adults (10 men, 9 women) completed a 4-h stay in a room calorimeter. Participants wore a footwear-based physical activity monitor as well as Actical, ActiGraph, IDEEA, DirectLife, and Fitbit devices. Each individual performed a series of postures/activities. We developed models to estimate EE from the footwear-based device, and we used the manufacturer’s software to estimate EE for all other devices. Results Estimated EE using the shoe-based device was not significantly different than measured EE (mean ± SE; 476 ± 20 vs 478 ± 18 kcal, respectively) and had a root-mean-square error of 29.6 kcal (6.2%). The IDEEA and the DirectLlife estimates of EE were not significantly different than the measured EE, but the ActiGraph and the Fitbit devices significantly underestimated EE. Root-mean-square errors were 93.5 (19%), 62.1 kcal (14%), 88.2 kcal (18%), 136.6 kcal (27%), 130.1 kcal (26%), and 143.2 kcal (28%) for Actical, DirectLife, IDEEA, ActiGraph, and Fitbit, respectively. Conclusions The shoe-based physical activity monitor provides a valid estimate of EE, whereas the other physical activity monitors tested have a wide range of validity when estimating EE. Our results also demonstrate that estimating EE based on classification of physical activities can be more accurate and precise than estimating EE based on total physical activity....Keywords
This publication has 37 references indexed in Scilit:
- Sedentary Behavior: Emerging Evidence for a New Health RiskMayo Clinic Proceedings, 2010
- A comprehensive evaluation of commonly used accelerometer energy expenditure and MET prediction equationsEuropean Journal of Applied Physiology, 2010
- Estimation of Free‐Living Energy Expenditure Using a Novel Activity Monitor Designed to Minimize ObtrusivenessObesity, 2010
- Caloric Restriction with or without ExerciseMedicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 2010
- Improving assessment of daily energy expenditure by identifying types of physical activity with a single accelerometerJournal of Applied Physiology, 2009
- Novel daily energy expenditure estimation by using objective activity type classification: where do we go from here?Journal of Applied Physiology, 2009
- Evaluation of Low‐Intensity Physical Activity by Triaxial AccelerometryObesity, 2007
- A novel method for using accelerometer data to predict energy expenditureJournal of Applied Physiology, 2006
- Predicting Activity Energy Expenditure Using the Actical® Activity MonitorResearch Quarterly for Exercise and Sport, 2006
- Validity of accelerometry for the assessment of moderate intensity physical activity in the fieldMedicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 2000