Conceptualizing Politics: Strategic or Communicative Action?
Authors:
- 1 September 1997
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Scandinavian Political Studies
- Vol. 20 (3) , 219-241
Abstract
Following the “behavioral revolution” in the social sciences, analyzing political behavior as strategic action has become a dominant paradigm in political science. However, many political processes become incomprehensible from a purely strategic angle. Only a concept of politics ascommunicativeaction can explain how people reach mutual agreements on factual and normative matters. Some analysts seem to assume that whenever actors take a position in a debate that coincides with their own interest, the employed arguments must be understood as a strategic device to promote this self‐interest But this explanation in most cases seems too simplistic and, from a communicative perspective, beside the point. In an open debate it will still be the rational weight of the arguments that matters, not the eventual strategic interests of the participants. Rational communication is a precondition for civilized conflict resolution as well as for the stability and durability of the political order.Max Weber provided us with a typology of goal‐oriented behavior which included, along with the rational self‐interest variety, which he calledZweckrationalität, or instrumental behavior,Wertrationalität, or absolute value‐oriented behavior, traditional or habitual behavior, and impulsive behavior. From this perspective we can see what a small part of the reality we, as social scientists, want to explain is captured by the rational choice model (Almond 1991, 49).Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Limits and Possibilities of Communicative Ethics for Democratic TheoryPolitical Theory, 1993
- Is Talk Really Cheap? Prompting Conversation between Critical Theory and Rational ChoiceAmerican Political Science Review, 1993
- Institutions and Social Conflict1992
- Rethinking Allison's ModelsAmerican Political Science Review, 1992
- Habermas on Strategic and Communicative ActionPolitical Theory, 1991
- Economic Behavior and Institutions1990
- The Cement of Society1989
- Nuts and Bolts for the Social Sciences1989
- Were They Pushed or Did They Jump?1987
- The Calculus of Consent1960