Discourses of Influence and Autonomy in Physicians’ Accounts of Treatment Decision Making for Depression
- 2 September 2011
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Qualitative Health Research
- Vol. 22 (2) , 238-249
Abstract
Models of patient–physician decision making are typically framed on a continuum of discourses and practices ranging from patient autonomy to physician paternalism, with the middle ground being occupied by terms such as shared decision making. Critiques of these models center on the gulf between these idealized models and actual practice and on how context influences decision-making practices. In this article I focus on how 11 Canadian family physicians talked about patient–physician decision making in interviews about their diagnostic and treatment practices for depression. I adopt a discursive approach to analyzing extracts from these interviews, and show how these physicians constructed themselves as engaging in acts of professional judgment and persuasion, and patients as having the final say in decision making about treatment for depression. I argue that whether the intertwining of discourses of physician influence and patient autonomy is understood as a balance of power between physicians and patients is an open question.Keywords
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- Can physicians both persuade and partner? A commentary on Karnieli-Miller and EisikovitsSocial Science & Medicine, 2009
- Physicians' Shared Decision-Making Behaviors in Depression CareArchives of internal medicine (1960), 2008
- Shared Decision Making in the Medical Encounter: Are We All Talking about the Same Thing?Medical Decision Making, 2007
- Effect of Mental Health Care and Shared Decision Making on Patient Satisfaction in a Community Sample of Patients with DepressionMedical Care Research and Review, 2007
- The effects of a shared decision-making intervention in primary care of depression: A cluster-randomized controlled trialPatient Education and Counseling, 2007
- The assessment of depressive patients’ involvement in decision making in audio-taped primary care consultationsPatient Education and Counseling, 2006
- Putting informed and shared decision making into practiceHealth Expectations, 2006
- Patient–doctor decision-making about treatment within the consultation—A critical analysis of modelsSocial Science & Medicine, 2006
- Experiencing depression, experiencing the depressed: The separate worlds of patients and doctorsJournal of Mental Health, 2001
- Positioning and Interpretative Repertoires: Conversation Analysis and Post-Structuralism in DialogueDiscourse & Society, 1998