Which Electrical Impedance Representations Generalize Across Biological Units? Cole–Cole Dispersion, Model Mismatch, and Nyquist Geometry in Tissue Classification
Authors:
- Syaiful AnamSASyaiful Anam
- Ahmad ZarkasiAZAhmad Zarkasi
- Zahari Md RodziZRZahari Md Rodzi
- Ahmad Hakiim JamaluddinAJAhmad Hakiim Jamaluddin
- Hilmi Aziz BukhoriHBHilmi Aziz Bukhori
Preprint
- 27 October 2026
- preprint
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract
Electrical impedance spectroscopy classifiers often use Cole–Cole or Nyquist descriptors, yet among 20 representative studies none separated Cole fit residuals from dispersion parameters, and only three reported patient-separated evaluation. We compared resistance–reactance spectra, Cole–Cole descriptors, local and global Nyquist-trajectory descriptors, and hybrids for generalization to unseen biological units on human bladder, porcine colon–rectum, and five human head-and-neck tasks. Validation held out patients or specimens, which served as inferential units; comparisons of selected candidates are exploratory. No representation was uniformly best, and raw spectra remained a strong baseline. In bladder tissue, which a single dispersion described well, Cole descriptors increased balanced accuracy from 86.1% to 97.3%, mostly through the dispersion parameters. In mucous tissue, which a single dispersion described poorly, a smaller gain (+4.4 points) was concentrated in the fit-residual descriptors. Fit adequacy indicated where Cole-derived information lay. Neither contrast survived multiplicity correction, although cluster-bootstrap intervals excluded zero. Under nested regularization tuning, the bladder contrast remained substantial (+15.1 points) and the mucous contrast decreased (+3.8 points); both intervals included zero. A unit-level audit found one bladder patient’s labels contradicting acquisition metadata, an inconsistency that had reduced all configurations to near chance and that patient referencing would not reveal; excluding this patient gave similar results. Most head-and-neck patients contributed one class per task, so these tasks mainly tested between-patient discrimination; most of their spectra failed a Kramers–Kronig check, leaving Cole descriptors descriptive only; lymph-node and muscle tasks remained at chance. A representation-selection workflow and a ten-item reporting checklist condense the findings.Keywords
This publication has 49 references indexed in Scilit:
- Classification of lung cancer tissue using bioimpedance spectroscopy and fractional-order circuit modelingPhysical and Engineering Sciences in Medicine, 2026
- Bioimpedance spectroscopy for characterizing volume-dependent structural changes in adipose tissueBiomedical Signal Processing and Control, 2026
- Improved bioimpedance spectroscopy tissue classification through data augmentation from generative adversarial networksMedical & Biological Engineering & Computing, 2023
- A filter-predictor polynomial feature based machine learning approach to predicting preterm birth from cervical electrical impedance spectroscopyBiomedical Signal Processing and Control, 2022
- Virtual Biopsy by Electrical Impedance Spectroscopy in Barrett’s CarcinomaJournal of Gastrointestinal Cancer, 2021
- Analysis of localized bioimpedance from healthy young adults during activities of the vocal folds using Cole-impedance model representationBiomedical Signal Processing and Control, 2021
- Smart needle to diagnose metastatic lymph node using electrical impedance spectroscopyAuris Nasus Larynx, 2021
- Evaluation of electrical characteristics of biological tissue with electrical impedance spectroscopyElectrophoresis, 2019
- Extremely randomized treesMachine Learning, 2006
- Electrical Properties of Tissue and Cell Suspensions1957