Cost effectiveness of adding magnetic resonance imaging to the usual management of suspected scaphoid fractures
Authors:
Open Access
- 21 January 2005
- journal article
- clinical trial
- Published by BMJ in British Journal of Sports Medicine
- Vol. 39 (2) , 75-79
Abstract
Objective: To determine the cost effectiveness of a magnetic resonance imaging scan (MRI) within 5 days of injury compared with the usual management of occult scaphoid fracture. Methods: All patients with suspected scaphoid fractures in five hospitals were invited to participate in a randomised controlled trial of usual treatment with or without an MRI scan. Healthcare costs were compared, and a cost effectiveness analysis of the use of MRI in this scenario was performed. Results: Twenty eight of the 37 patients identified were randomised: 17 in the control group, 11 in the MRI group. The groups were similar at baseline and follow up in terms of number of scaphoid fractures, other injuries, pain, and function. Of the patients without fracture, the MRI group had significantly fewer days immobilised: a median of 3.0 (interquartile range 3.0–3.0) v 10.0 (7–12) in the control group (p = 0.006). The MRI group used fewer healthcare units (median 3.0, interquartile range 2.0–4.25) than the control group (5.0, 3.0–6.5) (p = 0.03 for the difference). However, the median cost of health care in the MRI group ($594.35 AUD, $551.35–667.23) was slightly higher than in the control group ($428.15, $124.40–702.65) (p = 0.19 for the difference). The mean incremental cost effectiveness ratio derived from this simulation was that MRI costs $44.37 per day saved from unnecessary immobilisation (95% confidence interval $4.29 to $101.02). An illustrative willingness to pay was calculated using a combination of the trials measure of the subjects’ individual productivity losses and the average daily earnings. Conclusions: Use of MRI in the management of occult scaphoid fracture reduces the number of days of unnecessary immobilisation and use of healthcare units. Healthcare costs increased non-significantly in relation to the use of MRI in this setting. However, when productivity losses are considered, MRI may be considered cost effective, depending on the individual case.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- Cost-Effectiveness of Immediate MR Imaging Versus Traditional Follow-Up for Revealing Radiographically Occult Scaphoid FracturesAmerican Journal of Roentgenology, 2001
- Wrist Fractures: What the Clinician Wants to KnowRadiology, 2001
- Magnetic Resonance Imaging of Suspected Scaphoid Fractures Using a Low Field Dedicated Extremity MR SystemClinical Radiology, 2001
- Patient Rating of Wrist Pain and Disability: A Reliable and Valid Measurement ToolJournal of Orthopaedic Trauma, 1998
- Short tau inversion recovery magnetic resonance imaging in occult scaphoid injuries: Effect on managementAustralasian Radiology, 1998
- MR imaging of clinically suspected scaphoid fractures.American Journal of Roentgenology, 1997
- The diagnostic management of suspected scaphoid fractureInjury, 1997
- Magnetic Resonance Imaging of Occult Scaphoid FracturesThe Journal of Trauma: Injury, Infection, and Critical Care, 1996
- The utility of a bone scan in the diagnosis of clinical scaphoid fractureThe Journal of Emergency Medicine, 1994
- Occult Scaphoid FractureJournal of Orthopaedic Trauma, 1989